'Police Are Helpless': Bombay High Court Mulls Complete Ban On Sale Of Firecrackers In Mumbai, Says City Breathing Poisonous Gases
Narsi Benwal
20 Nov 2026 10:24 AM IST

Taking serious note of rising air and noise pollution levels in Mumbai, the Bombay High Court on Thursday (November 19) indicated that it was considering a complete ban on the sale and manufacture of firecrackers in the city.
A division bench of Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Dr Neela Gokhale observed that existing restrictions had failed to curb the indiscriminate bursting of firecrackers, particularly during Diwali, with violations continuing till 3β4 AM despite efforts by police and civic authorities.
Adding that citizens lacked sensitivity towards the harmful effects of pollution and that even the police machinery was helpless in controlling violations, the bench said drastic measures were necessary to protect public health and safety.
βIt's important that the sale of firecrackers is banned in totality. It's causing harm to properties of people, with over 300 cases of properties being damaged, reported during Diwali. Also, the mindset of people has not changed. They appear to have no consciousness for the societal cause. They have no sensitivity in regard to pollution. During Diwali, the AQI was the highest. The city is breathing poisonous gases. What happens to children, senior citizens, etc? With this, we'll have to take drastic measures," the judges said.
The bench made it clear that unless there is some proactive approach, nothing is going to change, as people will continue to purchase crackers till they are available. The judges took a serious note of the fact that despite efforts of the Police and civic authorities, citizens continued to flout the restrictions.
"Police are totally helpless, they did their best, but ultimately this is beyond control. We'll have to nip it in the bud and we'll have to ban all firecrackers in Mumbai. Only community firecrackers or fire show kind of thing will be allowed. We have air pollution, vehicular pollution, etc. we have to think about others. Even the decibel limits, it's beyond limits. They couldn't be controlled. Police machinery, to the best of their abilities, have taken steps. But those who are doing this don't care about the citizens," the judges said.
The judges noted that crackers are burnt not only during Diwali but also to celebrate cricket match, election victories and during processions, which violates the fundamental rights of other citizens.
"Over 350 properties have been damaged in the city during Diwali. We appreciate the steps taken by the Municipal Commissioner to ban the sale of aerial firecrackers but we also need to ban the noise causing crackers. This is for the society, nothing to do with a particular segment of people. If we don't take such steps, what will be left in the city is only upto one's imagination," the bench said.
The judges pointed out that all these incidents of violations have taken place despite clear cut orders of the High Court and observations made therein. The judges said manufacturers must consider the fundamental rights of other citizens over their own right to carry out business.
"If this is the situation, you have to think about the licences given for the sale of firecrackers. Common man don't know what kind of ingredients are used in the firecrackers, which are sold to them. If this is going to be a hazard for human life, State can't permit this. Authorities will not have a situation which can't be controlled by them. Everyone can't afford to have air purifiers at home. What about when you go out? What's the point of having orders or rules which are incapable of implementation? If the police is putting best of its effort, still they're not in a position to control, what's to be done? 210, 266 AQI? On 9th November (Diwali day), it was the highest. How Mumbai ignored every rule on Diwali? Even deaths have been reported due to firecracker injuries," the bench observed.
Weighing in, Justice Gokhale added, "The fact that AQI shot up cannot be denied. How do we salvage it? Don't be in denial mode, accept it and figure out how to combat it. Even if we go by your own report, the AQI is exceeding."
The judges while speaking about the incidents particularly about deaths of some persons due to crackers, said unless the firecrackers are not stopped from being made available, people will not purchase them.
"Reasonable restrictions in the interest of citizens is necessary. Pollution free environment is a basic need. Everything else is subservient. People have lost their lives, they have lost properties. Instead of celebrating, they were having a black Diwali for them. Safety of aircrafts also need to be taken care of. People bursting crackers till 3 to 4 AM. Why no sensitisation is there? Why are people not considering others? We don't understand. Is it neglect? Is it carelessness? Is it apathy? What is this?" the bench said.
The bench particularly took exception to the fact that social media is filled with instances where people are encouraging others to burst crackers.
With these observations, the bench reserved its order on the issue.

