Calcutta High Court Calls Abhishek Banerjee's Remarks Against Judiciary 'Painful', But Extends Interim Protection Till January 29
Srinjoy Das
20 Nov 2026 11:00 AM IST

The Calcutta High Court on Thursday extended the interim protection granted to Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee till January 29, observing that his alleged remarks against the judiciary, though “painful”, could not by themselves constitute a change in circumstances warranting denial of extension of the interim order.
Justice Saugata Bhattacharya was hearing the State's opposition to Banerjee's plea for extension of interim protection.
Additional Advocate General (AAG) Rajdeep Mazumdar drew the Court's attention to a tweet allegedly made by Banerjee against the judiciary after protection was denied to his aide. The AAG pointed out that Banerjee had already been accused of criminal contempt and questioned whether the Court could allow such remarks while continuing to extend protection to him.
The Court, however, questioned whether the alleged comments could be considered a ground to deny extension of interim protection in the present proceedings.
“Can prayer for extension of interim protection be denied based on comments against the judiciary? Is that wilful contumacious conduct?” the Court asked.
The AAG argued that protection was ordinarily granted to law-abiding citizens and questioned whether it could continue when the petitioner was allegedly making remarks attacking the judiciary.
The Court, however, repeatedly asked the State to demonstrate what change in circumstances justified denial of extension of the interim protection.
“If an appropriate situation comes, we may initiate contempt. That is a different proceeding. Can that issue be flagged for refusing interim protection?” the Court observed.
When the AAG sought time to file an affidavit, the Court directed the State to place on record a report disclosing the progress made in the investigation to enable it to consider the State's opposition to the extension.
The Court also questioned Banerjee's counsel about the remarks attributed to his client. When counsel stated that he would seek instructions and could not comment without knowing the circumstances, the Court asked how he could be unaware of his client's speech while representing him.
The Court directed Banerjee's counsel to file an affidavit by Monday.
The Court further remarked that comparative statements were being made about judicial orders passed at different points in time and cautioned that anyone aggrieved by an order should approach a higher forum rather than make remarks against the judiciary.
“If an MP is making such statement then what message is sent to his follower?” the Court asked.
It further observed that the remarks were painful, even if they might not amount to wilful and deliberate contempt.
“It is painful if it's found that the litigant is making comments against the court, even if it is not construed as a wilful deliberate violation,” the Court observed.
Banerjee's counsel stated that he did not subscribe to any comments made against the Court.
Ultimately, the Court held that the State had not demonstrated any alteration in circumstances warranting refusal to extend the interim protection. It also noted that the State had not established that Banerjee was not cooperating with the investigation.
“Today this court doesn't find any alteration of situation requiring refusal to extend interim order,” the Court observed.
Accordingly, the interim protection was extended till January 29, while granting the State an opportunity to file a report disclosing the progress made in the investigation.

