Car Parking Allotment Does Not Automatically Pass With Flat Sale Unless Expressly Conveyed: Calcutta High Court
Srinjoy Das
21 Nov 2026 2:45 PM IST

The Calcutta High Court has dismissed a writ petition filed by a flat owner seeking allotment of a car parking space which the West Bengal Housing Board had proposed to allot to the flat's previous owners, holding that the parking space did not automatically pass to him upon purchase of the apartment.
Justice Partha Sarathi Sen held that the petitioner had failed to establish that the car parking space was an inseparable incident of the flat or that it formed part of the property transferred to him under the registered deed of conveyance.
The Court was hearing a petition filed by Shrawan Kumar Agarwal challenging a September 19, 2019 memorandum issued by the West Bengal Housing Board, through which it revoked an earlier memorandum dated October 29, 1997, concerning allotment of a car parking space at the Golf Green Urban Complex.
The dispute arose from the purchase of Apartment No. 3A in the complex by Agarwal from Jayanta Kumar Basu and Anita Basu, who were its joint owners.
The Basus had applied to the Housing Board in November 1992 for allotment of a car parking space and deposited Rs 7,000. The Board initially issued a provisional allotment letter on December 18, 1992, in respect of parking space BG-3. Subsequently, on October 29, 1997, the Board decided to allot parking space BG-9 in the name of Jayanta Kumar Basu and expressed its intention to execute a deed of conveyance in due course.
However, the Basus had already transferred Apartment No. 3A to Agarwal through a registered deed of conveyance dated March 30, 1993. In a separate letter issued on the same date, they had assured him that they would hand over the car parking space once it was allotted to them by the Housing Board.
Agarwal contended that the allotment of the parking space should pass to him along with the flat by operation of Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. He argued that having purchased the apartment, he had stepped into the shoes of the previous owners and was entitled to the parking space proposed to be allotted to them. He also expressed his willingness to pay the requisite consideration, stamp duty and registration charges.
Opposing the plea, the Housing Board argued that the registered deed of conveyance transferring the flat did not contain any reference to a car parking space. It therefore contended that the petitioner could not claim an independent allotment merely on the basis of his purchase of the apartment.
Considering the rival submissions, the Court examined Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, which provides that a transfer of property ordinarily passes to the transferee all the interest which the transferor is capable of passing in the property and its legal incidents, unless a different intention is expressed or necessarily implied.
Justice Sen observed that although Section 8 provides for the transfer of legal incidents attached to a property, the petitioner had failed to establish that the disputed car parking space formed such an incident of the flat conveyed to him.
The Court noted that the schedule to the registered deed of conveyance dated March 30, 1993, which transferred Apartment No. 3A to the petitioner, did not mention any car parking space.
The judgment recorded:
“Since in course of his submission, Mr. Banerjee, learned senior advocate, places much reliance upon Section 8 of the said Act... this Court proposes to look to Section 8 of the said Act.”
It further held that the petitioner's argument was not tenable as he had failed to substantiate that the car parking space was an inseparable incident of the property transferred to him.
The Court observed that although the Housing Board had agreed to allot the parking space in the names of the petitioner's vendors, the transfer could not ultimately be effected. In such circumstances, it held that the vendors, and not the petitioner, would be the persons aggrieved by the failure to complete the allotment.
The Court further held that the Housing Board had never conveyed the car parking space to the previous owners, while the deed executed in favour of the petitioner did not provide for its automatic transfer along with the apartment.
Finding no merit in the writ petition, the Court dismissed WPA 2129 of 2020 as well as the connected interlocutory application, CAN 5 of 2026. It also vacated the interim order granted earlier. There was no order as to costs.
Case Title: Shrawan Kumar Agarwal v. The West Bengal Housing Board & Ors.

