Will's Propounder Must Prove Execution And Attestation; Failure To Prove Forgery Cannot Validate It: Chhattisgarh High Court
Saksham Vaishya
20 Nov 2026 3:15 PM IST

The Chhattisgarh High Court has held that the burden of proving a Will's due execution and attestation rests on the person propounding it, and cannot be shifted to the person challenging the Will merely because they have failed to establish forgery. The Court observed that a will cannot be used in evidence unless at least one attesting witness is called to prove its execution.
Justice Sachin Singh Rajput was hearing a second appeal filed against judgments dismissing the appellant's suit for declaration, partition and separate possession of agricultural land. The dispute concerned land originally owned by Shanti Bai, the maternal grandmother of the appellant and respondent No. 1, who were siblings. Their mother, Rukhmani Bai, had predeceased Shanti Bai. The appellant claimed that, in the absence of a valid Will or other alienation, she and her brother had inherited the property in equal shares.
The brother, however, claimed exclusive ownership on the basis of an unregistered Will dated October 6, 1999, allegedly executed by Shanti Bai in his favour. The appellant alleged that the Will was forged and challenged the mutation of the property in her brother's name.
The substantial question before the High Court was whether the courts below had acted perversely by upholding the Will while placing the burden of proving forgery on the appellant, rather than requiring the propounder to establish its due execution and attestation.
The Court referred to Sections 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, governing the execution and proof of Wills. It observed that a Will required by law to be attested cannot be used in evidence unless at least one attesting witness is called to prove its execution, where such a witness is alive and capable of giving evidence.
“… the document such as Will in the instant case which is required to be attested shall not be used as an evidence unless one attesting witness at least is called for the purpose of proving its due execution,” the Court remarked.
The Court noted that the brother, as the propounder, had failed to examine even one attesting witness. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision such as Chinu Rani Ghosh v. Subhash Ghosh, the Court reiterated that the propounder must establish due execution and attestation of the will.
The Court emphasised that the burden of proving a Will is distinct from the burden of proving forgery. It observed:
“Merely because the appellant/plaintiff has failed to establish that the Will was forged, the document cannot automatically be treated as genuine. The propounder must independently establish its due execution and attestation in accordance with law.”
Hence, the Court held that the petitioner cannot claim title as he failed to prove the execution of the will by leading cogent and clinching evidence. It further observed that merely exhibiting the document or recording a mutation entry could not, by itself, establish testamentary title.
The Court held the approach of the lower Court to be legally unsustainable as it had upheld the Will merely because the appellant/plaintiff failed to prove forgery, without first determining whether the propounder had proved its due execution and attestation.
The Court accordingly answered the substantial question of law in favour of the appellant, holding that the burden of proving due execution and attestation could not be shifted to her merely because she had alleged forgery.
Consequently, the Court allowed the second appeal, set aside the judgments of the courts below and declared the appellant entitled to a one-half share in the suit property.
Case Title: Bhula @ Bhagwati Thakur v. Manharan Singh Thakur & Ors. [Second Appeal No. 244 of 2017]

