Child's Right To Know Biological Father Can Outweigh Father's Right To Privacy: Delhi High Court Upholds DNA Test Order

  • Childs Right To Know Biological Father Can Outweigh Fathers Right To Privacy: Delhi High Court Upholds DNA Test Order
    Listen to this Article

    The Delhi High Court has observed that a child's right to know her biological parentage can outweigh the alleged father's right to privacy in appropriate circumstances.

    The division bench of Justices Vivek Chaudhary and Renu Bhatnagar upheld a Family Court's direction requiring a man to undergo a DNA test to determine the paternity of a girl.

    The Court observed that although the right to privacy is a fundamental right, it is not absolute and must be balanced against the child's right to know her biological origins.

    "The right of the appellant to privacy has to be balanced against the right of the respondent no.2 to know her origin, and in the facts of the present case, the balance tilts in favour of the latter," the Court observed.

    It further remarked: "Justice is best served by truth. Justice is not served by impeding the establishment of truth."

    The Court was hearing an appeal filed by a man challenging a Family Court order directing him to undergo a DNA test along with a girl whose mother claimed that he was her biological father.

    The woman claimed that she had married the appellant in 1997 and that they had subsequently lived together in Delhi and Gujarat. She alleged that the man left her in July 2010, during which period she had conceived the child, who was born in March 2011.

    The man however denied any relationship with the woman and the child's paternity. He claimed that he was married to another woman since 1999 and had two children from that marriage.

    Earlier, the woman had instituted proceedings seeking restitution of conjugal rights and maintenance. Both petitions were dismissed in 2012 after she failed to establish her marriage with the appellant. The High Court subsequently upheld those findings.

    Thereafter, the woman and her daughter instituted a separate suit seeking a DNA test to determine the child's paternity and a declaration that the appellant was her biological father.

    In August 2024, the Family Court directed the DNA test, observing that the failure to prove marriage was distinct from determining biological paternity.

    Challenging the order, the man argued that the earlier judgments had attained finality and that there was no prima facie material justifying a DNA test. He also contended that compelling him to undergo the test would violate his right to privacy.

    Rejecting these arguments, the Court observed that the earlier proceedings concerned the woman's marital status and did not determine the child's paternity. It noted that the daughter was not a party to those proceedings and that the findings regarding the absence of proof of marriage could not bind her on the question of biological parentage.

    The Court also distinguished cases where DNA testing is sought merely to establish adultery in matrimonial proceedings from cases where determining paternity is the very subject matter of the dispute.

    It noted that the woman's testimony regarding cohabitation with the appellant during the period of conception had neither been challenged during cross-examination nor rebutted by contrary evidence. The appellant had also not entered the witness box to disprove her assertion, it noted.

    The Court also rejected the argument that drawing an adverse inference against the man for refusing a DNA test would be sufficient to resolve the dispute.

    "Once a strong and eminent need is established, a child's right to know her parentage through the best available evidence cannot be denied by replacing scientific facts with a comparatively weak legal assumption," the Court observed.

    It held that an adverse inference from non-compliance could not substitute the scientific determination of biological paternity where a DNA test was necessary for establishing the truth.

    On the question of privacy, the Bench observed that although the right to privacy is a fundamental right, it is not absolute and can be reasonably curtailed.

    “The right of the appellant to privacy has to be balanced against the right of the respondent no.2 to know her origin, and in the facts of the present case, the balance tilts in favour of the latter. The apprehension of the appellant that the suit is aimed at defaming him can be taken care of by maintaining confidentiality, as was directed by the Supreme Court in Narayan Dutt Tiwari v. Rohit Shekhar (supra),” the Bench said.

    Accordingly, the Court upheld the Family Court's direction and dismissed the appeal.

    It directed the Family Court to fix an early date for the appellant and the daughter to appear before the Medical Superintendent or Head of Department, Forensic Medicine, BSA Hospital, for collection of samples.

    The Court further directed that the samples be collected confidentially and that the DNA report be forwarded to the Family Court in a sealed cover.

    It clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the actual question of paternity or the daughter's prayer for a declaration, which would be decided by the Family Court after considering the DNA report and the evidence on record.

    For Appellant: Ms. Archana Gaur, DHCLSC with Ms. Ridhima Gaur, Mr. Deepu Kumar, Advs.

    For Respondents: Ms. Kamlakshi Singh, DHCLSC

    Case Number :  Case No.: MAT.APP.(F.C.) 133/2025
    Next Story