Marriage To Indian Citizen Does Not Give Foreigner Enforceable Right To Stay In India Or Claim Spouse Visa: Delhi High Court

  • Marriage To Indian Citizen Does Not Give Foreigner Enforceable Right To Stay In India Or Claim Spouse Visa: Delhi High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Delhi High Court has observed that a foreign national does not have an enforceable right to reside in India or claim a particular category of visa merely on the basis of marriage to an Indian citizen.

    Justice Amit Mahajan observed that the entry and stay of foreign nationals in India are matters of sovereign discretion and not enforceable rights against the State.

    The Court made the observation while dismissing a plea filed by a US citizen seeking conversion of her existing e-Tourist Visa into an Entry (X-1)/Spouse Visa on the basis of her marriage to an Indian citizen.

    The petitioner, Lisa Hall Srivastava, had married Mohd. Wasim Akram on December 07, 2025, in accordance with Muslim rites and customs. Their marriage was subsequently solemnised before a Marriage Officer under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, on March 18.

    The woman approached the Court alleging that despite submitting the requisite documents for conversion of her visa, the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) had not favourably processed her application. She also alleged that she and her husband were subjected to repeated enquiries on account of the age difference between them.

    The Centre, in its counter affidavit, explained that the woman's immigration history and surrounding circumstances had been examined by the competent authority.

    It pointed out that the woman had previously been married twice and had sought immigration benefits on the basis of her earlier matrimonial relationships.

    It further stated that her first marriage had ended in July 2021, following which her OCI status was cancelled in November 2023. Her second marriage, solemnised in December 2022, ended in November 2025.

    The authorities also highlighted that the woman had been residing as a tenant in premises owned by her present husband even before their marriage and that he had also accompanied her during the period when she was pursuing immigration benefits on the basis of her previous marriage.

    Considering the said circumstances, the competent authority had formed a prima facie opinion that the marriage was a marriage of convenience and that the possibility of financial or contractual arrangements to facilitate immigration benefits could not be ruled out.

    Accepting the explanation furnished by the Centre, the Court observed:

    "The mere fact that the Petitioner has entered into a marriage with an Indian citizen does not, by itself, confer an automatic or indefeasible right to conversion of her existing visa into an Entry (X-1) Visa."

    The Court referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Louis De Raedt v. Union of India, wherein it was held that the fundamental rights of a foreign national are confined to Article 21 of the Constitution of India and do not include the right to reside and settle in India under Article 19(1)(e).

    It further relied on its decision in Randa Chehab v. Union of India, observing that the entry or stay of a foreign national in India is a matter of sovereign discretion.

    The Court also rejected the argument that the marriage certificate issued under the Special Marriage Act would prevent immigration authorities from examining the circumstances surrounding the marriage and the woman's eligibility for the visa sought.

    It noted that the husband had not filed an affidavit corroborating the woman's assertions regarding their matrimonial relationship and cohabitation.

    “While the absence of such an affidavit cannot, by itself, determine the genuineness or otherwise of the marriage, it is a relevant circumstance in considering the material placed before this Court in support of the Petitioner's claim,” the Court said.

    It further observed that it was not exercising its judicial review jurisdiction to substitute its own assessment for that of the competent authority in matters concerning the admission of foreign nationals.

    Clarifying that it had not adjudicated upon the validity or genuineness of the marriage, the Court said its observations were confined to the petitioner's claim for immigration benefits and the authorities' examination of her application.

    “If any representation is pending consideration or is filed in future, the same be decided by the Respondents, in accordance with law,” Justice Mahajan said.

    Case Title :  LISA HALL SRIVASTAVA v. UNION OF INDIA & ANR
    Nupur Thapliyal

    Nupur Thapliyal is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, based in New Delhi. She reports from the Delhi High Court and trial courts in the national capital

    Next Story