Private Insurance Companies Like HDFC Ergo Perform Public Functions, Amenable To Writ Jurisdiction: Delhi High Court

  • Private Insurance Companies Like HDFC Ergo Perform Public Functions, Amenable To Writ Jurisdiction: Delhi High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Delhi High Court has held that private insurance companies like HDFC Ergo perform functions of a public character and are amenable to the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, despite not being instrumentalities of the State.

    Justice Jasmeet Singh observed that insurance companies act as a social safety net for the general public and perform functions akin to those of the State.

    "In the modern welfare state, welfare functions are not undertaken by the State alone. In some cases, private bodies have also been entrusted with certain obligations towards the public. This is no different in the case of insurance companies, which act as a social safety net for the general public," the Court said.

    It further observed that although insurance companies and insured individuals are technically equal in the eyes of law, the former occupy a position of greater power.

    "Insurance companies deal with matters of a public nature and perform functions akin to those of the State," the Court said.

    The observations came while allowing a petition filed by a widow, challenging HDFC Ergo's rejection of an insurance claim following her husband's death due to cardiac arrest.

    The insurance company had raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the petition, arguing that it was a private entity and did not fall within the definition of "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution of India.

    Rejecting the objection, the Court observed that Article 226 confers wide powers on High Courts to review the actions of private entities performing functions of a public character.

    "I am of the view that even though the respondent No. 1 is a private entity and is not financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the control of the Government, the respondent No. 1 is still amenable to this Court's jurisdiction under Article 226."

    The Court referred to the Supreme Court's decisions on the scope of writ jurisdiction against private bodies and observed that the nature of the functions performed, rather than merely the legal status of the entity, was relevant.

    "Accordingly, a private body that owes a duty to the public cannot place its actions beyond the reach of judicial review," the Court said.

    The petitioner's husband and his brother had jointly purchased a residential property in Greater Noida after availing a home loan of ₹50 lakh. They had obtained a Home Credit Assure insurance policy from HDFC Ergo.

    Following her husband's death due to cardiac arrest in April 2021, the petitioner sought insurance coverage. However, the company rejected her claim on the ground that cardiac arrest was not covered under the specified critical illnesses. Her subsequent complaint before the Insurance Ombudsman was also dismissed.

    On examining the policy, the High Court held that the term "Myocardial Infarction", as defined in the insurer's own documentation, included cardiac arrest within its ambit.

    As such, the Court directed HDFC Ergo to pay the petitioner her late husband's 50% insured interest.

    For Petitioner: Mr. Shantnu Aggarwal, Adv.

    For Respodnents: Ms. Suman Bagga, Adv. For R-1 Mr. Abhishek Nanda, Ms. Hrishika Rawat, and Ms. Yashika Singh, Advs. for R-2

    Case Title :  Smt. Sushma Tyagi v. M/s HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited & Ors.Case Number :  W.P.(C) 168/2024
    Next Story