- Home
- /
- High Courts
- /
- Gauhati High Court
- /
- Contradictions In Child Victim's...
Contradictions In Child Victim's Statements Can't Be Ignored Merely Due To Tender Age: Gauhati High Court Sets Aside POCSO Conviction
Aryan Raj
19 Nov 2026 10:30 AM IST
While acquitting a man convicted under POCSO Act, the Gauhati High Court has held that material contradictions in the statements of a child victim cannot be overlooked merely because of her tender age.Justice Shamima Jahan examined the victim statements at three stages of the proceedings: before the police, before the Magistrate and before the trial court.The Court noted that in her...
This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers
Subscribe Premium
INR 1099+GST
Your support helps us to bring you more content at
an affordable subscription scheme !!!
All payment options available
While acquitting a man convicted under POCSO Act, the Gauhati High Court has held that material contradictions in the statements of a child victim cannot be overlooked merely because of her tender age.
Justice Shamima Jahan examined the victim statements at three stages of the proceedings: before the police, before the Magistrate and before the trial court.
The Court noted that in her statement recorded by the police under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), the victim had merely stated that the appellant had done something to her.
However, in her statement recorded before the Magistrate under Section 164 CrPC, she stated that the appellant had hurt her private parts, applied saliva there and pressed her mouth when she cried.
In her testimony before the trial court, the victim gave a different account, the court noted. It thus said:
“The discrepancies are writ large in the statement of the victim as narrated above...although it can safely be held that the victim being of such a minor age, cannot be expected to give consistent statement, to the exact sense of the term, before all the authorities but at the same time, the discrepancies seen in her statement cannot by any stretch, can be said to be connected or similar to each other. As such, this Court is duty bound to look into the other evidence on record".
The Court found that the three statements described substantially different acts and could not be treated as minor discrepancies arising from the victim's tender age.
Referring to the test of a “sterling witness” laid down by the Supreme Court, the Court reproduced the following observation in Rai Sandeep v. State of NCT of Delhi, (2012):
“What would be more relevant would be the consistency of the statement right from the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when the witness makes the initial statement and ultimately before the Court.”
The Court also found contradictions in the statements of the victim's mother and grandmother, who were relied upon by the prosecution for corroboration.
The mother had claimed before the trial court that she witnessed the assault. However, during cross-examination, she was confronted with her previous statement before the police. The Investigating Officer subsequently confirmed that she had not made such a statement during the investigation.
Similar contradictions were found in the grandmother's testimony regarding the appellant allegedly committing the offence in her presence and admitting his guilt. The Investigating Officer confirmed that the grandmother had not made those statements before the police.
The case arose from an incident dated August 8, 2017 when the prosecution alleged that the appellant entered the house of a five year old girl and sexually assaulted her while her mother was washing clothes outside. The mother allegedly rushed inside after hearing the child's cries and saw the appellant with the victim.
The Special Judge, Barpeta convicted the appellant under Section 450 IPC and Section 4 POCSO Act in March 2021. He was sentenced to seven years of rigorous imprisonment under the POCSO Act.
Challenging the conviction before the High Court the appellant argued that there were material contradictions in the statements of the prosecution witnesses. He also alleged that a land dispute between the parties had led to his false implication.
The Court also took note of the medical evidence. The doctor who examined the victim found swelling and tenderness in her labia but did not find any injury on her private parts. The victim had also named a different person during her medical examination.
In view of the material contradictions in the victim's statements and the absence of reliable corroborative evidence, the High Court held that interference with the conviction was warranted.
Accordingly, the Court set aside the judgment of the Special Judge, Barpeta, acquitted the appellant of the charges and directed his release if he was not required in any other case.
Counsel for Appellant: J. Ahmed
Amicus Curiae: B. Choudhury
For the State: B. Sarmah, Additional Public Prosecutor


