- Home
- /
- High Courts
- /
- Gauhati High Court
- /
- UPSC Consultation Not Mandatory In...
UPSC Consultation Not Mandatory In Disciplinary Proceedings Against Civilian Officers Of Border Roads Organisation: Gauhati High Court
Bhavya Singh
20 Nov 2026 2:30 PM IST
The Gauhati High Court has held that consultation with the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) is not necessary in disciplinary proceedings against civilian officers of the Border Roads Organisation (BRO).Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui, observed, "As such, that the petitioner being a Civilian Members of the BRO, is also members of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the...
This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers
Subscribe Premium
INR 1099+GST
Your support helps us to bring you more content at
an affordable subscription scheme !!!
All payment options available
The Gauhati High Court has held that consultation with the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) is not necessary in disciplinary proceedings against civilian officers of the Border Roads Organisation (BRO).
Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui, observed, "As such, that the petitioner being a Civilian Members of the BRO, is also members of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the Constitution of India and the BRO came under the Ministry of Defence only 2015, the provision of Regulation Clause 5 (2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958 squarely applies to the petitioner and there is no necessity for consultation with the UPSC."
The Regulation exempts the government from consulting the UPSC in disciplinary matters affecting a person belonging to a Defence Service (Civilian).
The observation came in a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution by one Kishori Saw, seeking quashing of the memorandum of charges from 2012, the enquiry report and the punishment order from 2015, along with consequential service benefits.
The petitioner was serving as Officer Commanding, 51 Road Construction Company at Leh, Jammu and Kashmir, when an accident took place involving alleged mishandling of explosives by personnel below him. Following a departmental enquiry, the disciplinary authority held the charges to be partially proved and imposed a penalty of withholding three increments without cumulative effect.
The petitioner submitted that the entire departmental proceeding was conducted in contravention of the DoPT guidelines dated 10.05.2011 and 05.03.2014. It was contended that the enquiry report, together with his representation, should have been sent to the UPSC for advice.
The respondents submitted that under Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, it was not necessary to consult the Commission in any disciplinary matter affecting a person belonging to Defence Service (Civilian). They further relied on the Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum dated 24.10.2019, which clarified that the said provision would apply to serving GREF officers of BRO.
The High Court, while examining the DoPT guidelines, observed, "The Department of Personnel & Training (DOP&T) guidelines issued vide Office Memorandum dated 10.05.2011 being statutory in nature, the compliance of which are mandatory in nature."
The Court further noted that the enquiry report and the petitioner's representation ought to have been forwarded to the UPSC for advice, which should thereafter have been furnished to the petitioner to enable him to submit his representation.
However, considering the nature of the proceedings, the Court observed, "No doubt the army authorities are also the controlling authorities insofar as BRO and GREF is concerned, however, in the facts of the present proceedings, the authority merely recommended initiation of departmental proceedings against the petitioner. There was no recommendation for court-martial proceedings against the writ petitioner as per the procedure prescribed under the Army Act read with the rules."
The Court further considered the Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum dated October 24, 2019, which clarified the applicability of Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, to serving GREF officers of the BRO in disciplinary proceedings under the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
It held that the petitioner, being a civilian member of the BRO, was also a member of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the Constitution and that consultation with the UPSC was not necessary.
Accordingly, the High Court, held, "In view of the discussion above, this Court does not find any merit in the petition seeking the interference of this Court to interfere with the Departmental Proceeding, Impugned Enquiry report and the Impugned Punishment Order dated 27.11.2015 issued against the petitioner and further to issue any consequential orders."
The writ petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
Bhavya Singh
Reporter


