Cheque Dishonoured With Remark 'Bank Merged' Can Still Lead To NI Act Prosecution: Gauhati High Court

  • Cheque Dishonoured With Remark Bank Merged Can Still Lead To NI Act Prosecution: Gauhati High Court

    The Gauhati High Court has held that dishonour of cheque on ground of merger of two banks does not by itself bar prosecution under Section138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.The Court was hearing a petition filed by M/s Naman Enterprise seeking to quash a complaint filed by M/s Gopi Mohan Drug Distributor along with the Magistrate's order taking cognizance and issuing a bailable...

    The Gauhati High Court has held that dishonour of cheque on ground of merger of two banks does not by itself bar prosecution under Section138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

    The Court was hearing a petition filed by M/s Naman Enterprise seeking to quash a complaint filed by M/s Gopi Mohan Drug Distributor along with the Magistrate's order taking cognizance and issuing a bailable warrant.

    The complainant alleged that Rs. 75,650 remained unpaid against goods supplied to the petitioner on credit. It claimed that the petitioner issued a cheque dated December 4, 2024 for the said amount drawn on the erstwhile Allahabad Bank. However, the cheque was returned unpaid with the remark “Bank merged”.

    Justice Shamima Jahan held that whether the cheque became invalid following the bank merger and whether it was issued towards a legally enforceable debt are disputed questions that must be examined by the trial court.

    “In the present case, since the cheque allegedly issued by the petitioner towards discharge of lawful liability as stated by the complainant was returned unpaid by the Indian Bank on the ground of merger, it cannot be presumed that the complainant was aware of the legal or contractual consequences flowing from the merger of Allahabad Bank with the Indian Bank...The complainant could not be reasonably expected to know that cheques issued by Account holders of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank, had become invalid after the merger and that the Indian Bank was under no obligation to honour such cheques. These are matters lying within the exclusive knowledge of the concerned banking institutions and cannot, by themselves, be a ground for a bar to a suit under Section 138 of the Act.”

    The court said that whether there was a lawfully recoverable debt from the petitioner or as to whether the cheque was issued by the petitioner in discharge of his liability towards the complainant or whether the cheque was issued as a security cheque wayback to the complainant are matters that the Trial Court will examine.

    This will be done by taking into account, the evidence adduced before it and also by keeping in view the statutory presumption that the cheque will be considered to have been given for valid consideration unless rebutted by the petitioner, it added. 

    The petitioner argued that the cheque had been issued years earlier as security and that no legally enforceable debt remained outstanding. It further contended that Allahabad Bank had merged with Indian Bank with effect from April 1, 2020 and that the cheque could not attract prosecution under Section 138 of the Act.

    The High Court observed that the complainant could not reasonably be expected to know the legal or contractual consequences of the merger or whether Indian Bank was obliged to honour cheques issued by account holders of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank. Such matters, the Court said, fall within the knowledge of the concerned banking institutions and cannot by themselves, bar proceedings under Section 138.

    Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the petition and refused to interfere with the pending cheque dishonour complaint.

    Counsel for Petitioner: Advocate W. Raja.

    Counsel for Respondents: M.P. Goswami appeared for the State of Assam; Advocate M. Agarwalla appeared for the complainant.

    Next Story