Gauhati High Court Restores Compulsory Retirement Of Cop Accused Of Rape, Says Acquittal Doesn't Undo Departmental Penalty

  • Gauhati High Court Restores Compulsory Retirement Of Cop Accused Of Rape, Says Acquittal Doesnt Undo Departmental Penalty
    Listen to this Article

    The Gauhati High Court has set aside an order directing the reinstatement of a Police constable accused of raping a minor girl and restored the penalty of compulsory retirement, holding that his acquittal in the criminal case several years later was not sufficient to invalidate the punishment imposed in departmental proceedings.

    A Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Kaushik Goswami observed that:

    “And in any case, Acquittal in a criminal case of a Police Constable is not always conclusive of the suitability of the person in such post. It is very difficult for us to believe that the respondent was falsely involved in the case.”

    A departmental enquiry was initiated against Respondent over allegations of raping a minor girl. The victim and her mother supported the allegation during the enquiry following which the Enquiry Officer found the charges proved and the disciplinary authority imposed compulsory retirement.

    Although Respondent was subsequently acquitted in the criminal trial after the victim failed to identify him in court, a Single Judge set aside the departmental punishment and directed his reinstatement with back wages and other benefits. The State challenged this decision before the Division Bench of High Court.

    The High Court noted that the victim had narrated the events during the departmental proceeding and that her mother had also supported the allegation. Official witnesses had additionally given evidence before the Enquiry Officer.

    “Under such circumstances, we reiterate, acquittal of the respondent in the criminal case many years after the occurrence would be no ground for setting aside the punishment in the Departmental Proceeding; more so while keeping in mind the nature of the job that the respondent was entrusted with, namely, policing,”

    On the claim of honourable acquittal, the High Court clarified that the expression was not synonymous with being fully exonerated.

    “Only when the accused is acquitted after full consideration of prosecution evidence and it is found that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the charges levelled against the accused, then only it can possibly be said that the accused has been honourably acquitted”

    The High Court also emphasised that police personnel must possess impeccable character and integrity by referring to the Supreme Court's decisions in Commissioner of Police, New Delhi Versus Mehar Singh, (2013) 7 SCC 685 and State of Madhya Pradesh Versus Parvez Khan, (2015) 2 SCC 591.

    On the absence of a Presenting Officer during the departmental enquiry, the Bench acknowledged that such an appointment was necessary. However, it held that the enquiry was not vitiated as the constable had been present and was permitted to cross examine the witnesses.

    “The tenor of the questions put by the respondent to the witnesses clearly indicate that he understood the entire gravamen of charges against him,”

    The High Court accordingly allowed the State's appeal, set aside the Single Judge's judgment and restored the penalty of compulsory retirement.

    Counsel for the Appellants: Senior Advocate D. Nath assisted by N. Paul.

    Counsel for the Respondent: Senior Advocate S. Dutta assisted by P.K. Deka.

    Case Title :  State of Assam & Ors. versus Habizur Rahman LaskarCase Number :  Writ Appeal No. 284 of 2026
    Next Story