Gauhati High Court Refuses To Enhance Accident Compensation As Claimant Fails To Prove Serious Injury Or Inability To Work

  • Gauhati High Court Refuses To Enhance Accident Compensation As Claimant Fails To Prove Serious Injury Or Inability To Work
    Listen to this Article

    The Gauhati High Court has dismissed an appeal seeking enhancement of motor accident compensation after finding no material to show that the appellant had suffered a fracture or was unable to carry out any work.

    Justice Devashis Baruah observed, "No other materials were placed on record except certain vouchers. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant could not show any material indicating that the Appellant's hand was fractured or that he was unable to carry out any work."

    The observation came in an appeal against a 2009 judgment and award, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kamrup at Guwahati.

    The appellant, Md. Moharuddin Haque, sought enhancement of compensation on the ground that the amount awarded was not just and reasonable as contemplated under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

    The case arose from an accident in June, 2004, when the appellant was riding a bicycle with Tafajul Hoque seated on its carrier. A vehicle hit the bicycle from behind, causing injuries to the appellant, while Tafajul Hoque succumbed to his injuries. Two claim proceedings were filed, one by the mother of the deceased and the other by the appellant.

    The Tribunal found that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle. It awarded Rs. 3,22,500 to the mother of the deceased and Rs. 20,000 to the appellant, comprising Rs. 10,000 towards medical expenses and Rs. 10,000 towards pain and suffering. The appellant preferred the appeal on February 23, 2015, six years after the award.

    The High Court, upon examining the materials on record, noted that the appellant had exhibited the police report, discharge report from GNRC, prescriptions and vouchers, X-ray report and CT scan of the brain.

    Referring to the discharge report, the Court noted, "The said discharge report mentions that at the time of presentation, the Appellant complained of mild headache and generalized body pain."

    The Court further noted that soft tissue abrasions were found over the left forehead, left shoulder, dorsum of the left hand and left knee joint. There was also abrasion with bruise and laceration over the left elbow, swelling of the right ankle and left calf and tenderness over the left shin. The appellant was discharged on request as desired by his attendants.

    The Court observed, "Upon being cross-examined, the Appellant stated that according to the hospital discharge certificate, he was fully cured."

    Accordingly, the Court held, "Considering the above, this Court does not find the present case to be a fit case for enhancement of compensation. Accordingly, the instant Appeal stands dismissed."

    The Court dismissed the appeal without imposing costs.

    It further directed that if the insurance company had not deposited the compensation awarded to the appellant, the same shall be deposited within four weeks along with interest from the date of filing of the claim petition.

    Click here to read the judgment

    Case Title :  Md. Moharuddin Haque v. The National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.Case Number :  MACApp./53/2015
    Bhavya Singh

    Reporter

    Next Story