- Home
- /
- High Courts
- /
- Gujarat High Court
- /
- 28 Years On, Gujarat High Court...
28 Years On, Gujarat High Court Upholds Acquittal In POCSO Case; Cites Faulty TIP
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
21 Nov 2026 10:15 AM IST
The Gujarat High Court upheld a trial court order acquitting a man in a POCSO case noting that the prosecution failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt the identification of the accused in the Test Identification Parade (TIP) conducted by the Magistrate. The court also observed that the IO did not follow the procedure for TIP properly nor did the Executive Magistrate comply with the...
This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers
Subscribe Premium
INR 1099+GST
Your support helps us to bring you more content at
an affordable subscription scheme !!!
All payment options available
The Gujarat High Court upheld a trial court order acquitting a man in a POCSO case noting that the prosecution failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt the identification of the accused in the Test Identification Parade (TIP) conducted by the Magistrate.
The court also observed that the IO did not follow the procedure for TIP properly nor did the Executive Magistrate comply with the legal requirements.
The court was hearing state's appeal challenging acquittal of the accused back in 1998.
A division bench of Justice Bhargav D Karia and Justice Hemant M Prachchhak said:
"So far as the identification of the accused is concerned, the same creates serious doubt. On perusal of the testimonies of the victim and the complainant, it emerges that the prosecution has failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt the identification of the accused in the Test Identification Parade (T.I. Parade) conducted by the Magistrate. It further appears that the Investigating Officer did not properly follow the prescribed procedure while conducting the T.I. Parade and the Executive Magistrate also failed to comply with the mandatory requirements of law".
The court also took note of examining doctor's testimony which stated that the victim had stated that she suffered injuries after falling down while playing and had not disclosed any details regarding the alleged incident as narrated by the complainant father.
The court also took note of deposition of independent witness who stated that when she saw the victim and inquired about her injuries, the victim informed her that she had fallen down while playing.
The court also took note of scientific evidence including the serological report and the other documentary evidence on record and said that the prosecution had failed to bring on record any cogent evidence connecting the accused with the crime in question.
The serological report reveals that the prosecution had not collected the blood samples either of the victim or the accused.
"Consequently, the prosecution has failed to establish the necessary link connecting the accused with the alleged crime and has also failed to prove his involvement in the alleged offence beyond reasonable doubt. In view of the evidence adduced by the prosecution, it appears that the learned Sessions Judge has discussed the facts and circumstances of the case in detail and after appreciating the depositions of the prosecution witnesses, recorded reasons in Paragraphs 6 to 10 and thereafter, in Paragraph 11 onwards, explained the reasons for not accepting the prosecution case. The prosecution has also failed to establish any fundamental fact through independent evidence connecting the accused with the crime in question. In the absence of cogent and reliable evidence establishing the involvement of the accused, the prosecution cannot be said to have proved the charges beyond reasonable doubt," the court said.
The court said that the Sessions Judge, after considering the relevant circumstances including the considerable delay in lodging the FIR, the inconsistent history given by the victim before the doctors at the initial stage of treatment, the doubtful identification of the accused in the T.I. Parade and absence of any clinching evidence had rightly concluded that the prosecution had failed to establish the charges against the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
The court also noted that the victim in her history disclosed before two doctors never mentioned anything regarding the alleged offence committed by the accused.
"Further, the manner in which the T.I. Parade was conducted by the Investigating Officer also creates serious doubt as the prescribed precautions and procedure were not duly followed. In the absence of any clinching evidence against the accused, the prosecution has failed to prove the charges for the alleged offences beyond reasonable doubt," the court added.
The appeal was dismissed.


