Agreement U/S 12 J&K Agrarian Reforms Act Presupposes Prior Section 4 Mutation; Cannot Be Used By Landlord To Surrender Ownership Rights: J&K&L High Court
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
19 Nov 2026 3:55 PM IST

The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has held that an agreement under Section 12 of the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976, presupposes the prior attestation of a mutation under Section 4 of the Act and cannot be used by a landlord to surrender ownership rights.
The High Court dismissed an intra-court appeal asserting ownership under mutations that followed a 1982 agreement through which the landlord had purportedly relinquished his rights in favour of the appellants' predecessor-in-interest.
A Division Bench of Justice Sanjeev Kumar and Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani observed,
“With a view to transferring the land covered by the Act, the erstwhile landlord, Brij Lal, and the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants entered into a deal and, in the first instance, executed an agreement purportedly under Section 12 of the Agrarian Reforms Act. As per this purported agreement, the landlord Brij Lal surrendered and relinquished all his ownership rights in favour of the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants. This was a procedure totally unknown to law”.
The Court further added: “Needless to say that, an agreement under Section 12 of the Agrarian Reforms Act can only be entered into between an 'ex-owner' and a 'prospective owner,' and that too solely with respect to the payment of an agreed amount or for admitting the apportionment of the land between themselves in an agreed manner. The expression 'ex-owner' of the land used in Section 12 presupposes the prior attestation of a mutation under Section 4 of the Act.”
The dispute concerned agricultural land originally recorded in a landlord's name. The revenue record showed the private respondents' father in cultivating possession during the statutory cut-off period and until 1980. The appellants' predecessor-in-interest was recorded as a tenant only thereafter.
In 1982, an agreement purportedly made under Section 12 of the Act was executed between the landlord and the appellants' predecessor-in-interest. It stated that the landlord had surrendered his ownership rights in favour of the latter. The agreement was attested before any mutation had been recorded under Section 4 of the Act.
A mutation under Section 4 later treated the appellants' predecessor-in-interest as the prospective owner. A subsequent mutation under Section 8 conferred ownership rights upon him.
The private respondents challenged both mutations. The Commissioner Agrarian Reforms set them aside and ordered a fresh inquiry. The Tehsildar then attested a Section 4 mutation in favour of the private respondents. Challenges before the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms, the Special Tribunal and the Writ Court failed.
In the intra-court appeal, the appellants contended that the land had been recorded as barren during the statutory cut-off period and could not have been cultivated by the private respondents or anyone else.
They further argued that the absence of any recorded payment of rent meant that no landlord-tenant relationship had arisen and that the private respondents were consequently not entitled to the benefits of Sections 4 and 8 of the Act.
Court's Observations
The High Court, at the outset, held that the attempted surrender followed a procedure unknown to law because Section 12 was confined to agreed payment or apportionment between an ex-owner and a prospective owner.
The statutory sequence was material because the landlord could acquire the status of an ex-owner only after the land had vested in the State through a mutation under Section 4.
The Court further noted that the revenue record showed the private respondents' father in cultivating possession during the relevant period and for several years thereafter. The appellants' predecessor-in-interest appeared as a cultivating tenant only in 1980.
The Court remarked that the appellants' contention that the land was barren during the statutory cut-off period was inconsistent with the subsequent mutation treating their predecessor-in-interest as a tiller in cultivating possession during that same period.
The Court stated,
“If we were to accept the argument of the learned counsel for the appellants that the land was banjar (unculturable) in the year 1971, it remains unexplained as to how the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants could simultaneously be shown as a tiller in cultivating possession in Kharif 1971.”
The Court held that any claim that the appellants' predecessor-in-interest had been cultivating the land during the relevant period, despite the revenue record showing otherwise, had to be raised before a Revenue Officer not below the rank of Tehsildar during the attestation of the Section 4 mutation.
Rule 4 required an opportunity of hearing to be given to all stakeholders, particularly the landlord and the person already recorded as the cultivating tenant. The Court found that this procedure had not been followed. Instead, the mutation under Section 4 was directly attested in favour of the appellants' predecessor-in-interest and was followed by the mutation under Section 8. The Commissioner Agrarian Reforms and the Special Tribunal had therefore rightly set those mutations aside.
The Court noted that the fresh Section 4 mutation in favour of the private respondents had been sustained by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms and the Special Tribunal. The Writ Court had also relied on the cultivation entries and the failure to follow Rule 4, while finding that the appellants' predecessor-in-interest was not in actual physical cultivation during the relevant period.
Concurring with those findings, the Division Bench stated,
“We also see no reason or justification to take a view different from the one taken by the Writ Court.”
The High Court, accordingly, dismissed the intra-court appeal and affirmed the Writ Court's decision.
It consequently left undisturbed the concurrent orders sustaining the fresh mutation under Section 4 in favour of the private respondents and rejecting the claim founded on the earlier Section 12 agreement and the subsequent mutations obtained by the appellants' predecessor-in-interest.
Appearances
For Appellants: M.Y. Bhat, Senior Advocate; Urba Nazir and Sajid Ahmad, Advocates
For Respondents: Vaseem Aslam, Advocate

