Jharkhand High Court Directs Improvements To AIIMS Deoghar Infra In MP Nishikant Dubey's PIL, Cites Right To Healthcare

  • Jharkhand High Court Directs Improvements To AIIMS Deoghar Infra In MP Nishikant Dubeys PIL, Cites Right To Healthcare
    Listen to this Article

    The Jharkhand HC has held that the effective functioning of tertiary healthcare institutions such as AIIMS Deoghar is intrinsically linked to the State's constitutional obligation under Article 21 of the Constitution. The Court observed that access to hospital facilities and timely medical care forms an integral part of the right to life and that ensuring adequate infrastructure at such institutions is not merely an administrative matter.

    A Division Bench of Chief Justice M.S. Sonak and Justice Manoj Prasad issued several time-bound directions concerning electricity supply, drinking water, fire safety, land encroachments and other infrastructure facilities at AIIMS Deoghar while disposing of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by Member of Parliament Nishikant Dubey.

    The PIL sought directions to make AIIMS Deoghar fully functional and operational to ensure the availability of quality tertiary healthcare facilities to the people of Jharkhand. Emphasising the constitutional significance of ensuring functional healthcare institutions, the Court observed:

    “These pronouncements make it clear that the effective functioning of tertiary care institutions, such as the AIIMS Deoghar Facility, is not merely an administrative matter but is intrinsically linked to the fulfilment of the State's constitutional obligation under Article 21”

    The Bench identified seven principal infrastructure issues requiring consideration, including uninterrupted electricity supply, establishment of a Kendriya Vidyalaya, direct water supply from Punasi Dam, fire safety, land encroachments, construction of a railway overbridge and permission for a diesel storage tank to operate generator sets.

    On electricity supply, the petitioner submitted that the hospital suffered from power cuts and voltage fluctuations, compelling it to rely heavily on diesel generators for critical care units, diagnostic equipment and life-saving devices. The Court noted that the State Government had commenced construction of a dedicated 132/33 KV grid substation and had reported substantial progress. It directed the concerned authorities to complete and operationalise the substation as expeditiously as possible, and in any event within six months of the judgment.

    On the establishment of a Kendriya Vidyalaya, the petitioner contended that specialist and qualified doctors were reluctant to work at AIIMS Deoghar because of inadequate educational facilities for their children. The Court observed that a temporary school facility was insufficient and that land had already been earmarked for establishing a full-fledged Kendriya Vidyalaya. However, a portion of the land was reportedly encroached upon. Accordingly, the Bench directed the State authorities to expedite proceedings against encroachers and make the land available to the Central Government, preferably within six months, while observing all legal procedures and principles of natural justice.

    Regarding water supply, the Court considered the proposal to provide direct water supply from Punasi Dam to meet the hospital's present and future requirements. It noted that although the State had accepted the proposal in principle, no significant progress had been made beyond preliminary paperwork and the proposed appointment of a consultant for preparing a Detailed Project Report. The Court observed:

    “The respondents must realise that uninterrupted water and electricity supplies are vital to the effective functioning of the AIIMS Deoghar Facility. Therefore, all necessary steps must be taken expeditiously to ensure these twin aspects if the AIIMS Deoghar Facility is to function at its optimum.”

    The Bench directed the State Government to expedite the project and file a compliance report within six months.

    On fire safety, the petitioner highlighted that some buildings at AIIMS Deoghar extended up to 24 floors, whereas ordinary fire tenders could reasonably access only the fifth or sixth floor. He also referred to a major fire incident on April 13, 2023, which caused property damage but no loss of life because the hospital was not functional at the time. The Court directed the State Government to expedite the measures being undertaken to address fire safety concerns and submit a compliance report within six months.

    The Bench also examined the issue of land encroachments. According to the petitioner, although 237 acres had been earmarked and allotted to AIIMS Deoghar, possession of only 217 acres had been handed over. The Court directed the State Government to file an affidavit within six months explaining the extent of encroachments, the steps taken for their removal and the status of the proceedings.

    Regarding the railway overbridge near AIIMS Deoghar, the Court noted that ongoing construction had caused severe traffic congestion. It directed that the project, if still incomplete, be completed within three months. The Court further directed the State Government to take expeditious steps to secure the necessary NOC for the Petroleum Class B High-Speed Diesel storage tank required to operate the hospital's diesel generator sets and submit a compliance report within six months.

    Explaining the purpose of public interest litigation, the Bench observed:

    “The purpose of public interest litigation is to activate the Executive to take expeditious steps to redress a grievance with a public element. This purpose has been substantially achieved. This is because some issues have been sorted out, and on most of the remaining issues, the State Government authorities are taking steps towards redressal”

    The Court held that since the State authorities were aware of the deficiencies and had begun taking steps to address them, there was no purpose in keeping the PIL pending. Accordingly, the High Court disposed of the PIL while directing the State Government to file a comprehensive compliance report detailing the progress made on the identified issues on or before May 7, 2027.

    The Court directed that an advance copy of the report be furnished to the petitioner's counsel and listed the matter for orders on May 13, 2027, to consider compliance.

    Appearance:

    For the Petitioner: Mr. Diwakar Upadhayay, Advocate

    For the Union of India: Mr. Prashant Kumar Singh, Deputy Solicitor General of India; Mr. Karbir, A.C. to D.S.G.I.

    For the State: Mr. Vibhor Mayank, A.C. to Advocate General

    For JBVNL: Mr. Mohan Kumar Dubey, Standing Counsel; Mr. Utpal Kant, A.C. to S.C.-JBVNL

    For Respondent No. 13: Mr. Vijay Shanker Jha, Advocate

    Case Title :  Nishikant Dubey v. Union of India and OrsCase Number :  W.P. (PIL) No. 2419 of 2022
    Next Story