'Husband Must Establish Wife's Knowledge Of Restitution Decree And Intentional Desertion To Justify Divorce': Jharkhand High Court
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
19 Nov 2026 2:35 PM IST

The Jharkhand HC has held that a husband seeking divorce on the ground of non-compliance with a decree for restitution of conjugal rights must establish that his wife was aware of the decree and had failed to resume matrimonial cohabitation despite such knowledge. The Court further held that mere separation between spouses does not establish desertion unless there is evidence of an intention to permanently end matrimonial cohabitation.
A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Akhil Kumar upheld the dismissal of a husband's divorce petition, observing that he had failed to establish either his wife's wilful refusal to resume cohabitation despite knowledge of the restitution decree or the requisite intention to desert him.
The case arose from a marriage solemnised on May 11, 1995, in Ranchi. Two sons were born from the marriage. According to the husband, disputes arose in 2013 when his wife allegedly began insisting that he relocate to Bhuli, Dhanbad, to reside with her retired parents. He claimed that on April 13, 2013, his wife left the matrimonial home in Ranchi along with their children and went to her parental residence. Despite his repeated efforts to bring them back, she allegedly refused to return and insisted that he settle in Dhanbad.
The husband subsequently instituted proceedings under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, seeking restitution of conjugal rights. The Family Court allowed his petition ex-parte on November 11, 2016. He also alleged that his wife had instituted a criminal complaint against him under Sections 498-A, 323 and 506 IPC in 2013 on false and fabricated allegations. According to the husband, attempts at reconciliation, including mediation proceedings before JHALSA, Ranchi, did not result in the permanent restoration of matrimonial cohabitation.
He thereafter approached the Family Court seeking dissolution of marriage under Section 13(1A)(ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, relying principally on the alleged failure to resume conjugal life despite the restitution decree. However, by judgment dated March 19, 2025, the Additional Principal Judge, Additional Family Court-I, Ranchi, dismissed his divorce petition.
Aggrieved, the husband approached the High Court. Examining Section 13(1A)(ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, the Bench noted that the provision permits either party to seek dissolution of marriage where there has been no restitution of conjugal rights for one year or more after a decree under Section 9.
The Court observed that the Family Court had rejected the husband's claim because he had failed to produce cogent and trustworthy evidence establishing that his wife knew about the ex-parte restitution decree and had wilfully refused to resume matrimonial life despite such knowledge. Agreeing with the Family Court, the High Court held that the husband had failed to establish through reliable evidence that his wife had not resumed conjugal life despite being aware of the decree dated November 11, 2016.
The Bench also examined whether the wife's separate residence amounted to matrimonial desertion. It noted that although the parties had been living separately, physical separation alone was insufficient to establish desertion. The essential requirement of animus deserendi, or the intention to permanently terminate matrimonial cohabitation, also had to be established. On the absence of such intention, the Court observed:
“Further, in the facts of the present case, although the factum of separation between the parties stands established, the appellant has failed to prove that the respondent had the requisite intention to bring matrimonial cohabitation permanently to an end. The evidence available on record does not disclose the existence of animus deserendi on the part of the respondent. Rather, the materials on record, including her categorical assertion expressing willingness to reside with the appellant, indicate that her separate residence was not driven by an intention to forsake the marital relationship permanently, but was a consequence of the prevailing circumstances. As such, one of the essential ingredients constituting desertion remains unproved, and the plea of desertion advanced by the appellant cannot be said to have been established in accordance with law.”
The Court placed significance on the wife's categorical assertion that she was willing to reside with her husband, observing that her separate residence did not demonstrate an intention to permanently abandon the matrimonial relationship.
The Bench consequently found that the husband had failed to establish the grounds relied upon for dissolution of marriage and upheld the Family Court's refusal to grant divorce.
Case Number:
Appearance:
For the Appellant-Husband: Mr. Anurag Kashyap, Advocate; Ms. Kanika Sinha, Advocate
For the Respondent-Wife: Mr. Sanjay Prasad, Advocate

