'Natural Guardian Need Not Obtain Court Declaration Of Guardianship To Seek Child's Custody': Jharkhand High Court
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
20 Nov 2026 1:25 PM IST

The Jharkhand HC has held that Sections 7 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 operate in distinct statutory fields, and a natural guardian seeking restoration of a minor child's custody under Section 25 need not necessarily obtain a prior court declaration of guardianship under Section 7. The Court observed that a custody petition cannot be rejected at the threshold merely because the applicant has not previously been appointed or declared a guardian by a competent court.
A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava set aside a Family Court order rejecting a father's petition for custody of his minor son, holding that the court had incorrectly treated a prior declaration of guardianship as a mandatory condition for invoking Section 25.
The case arose from a matrimonial dispute between a couple married on December 10, 2017. Their son was born on June 19, 2020. According to the father, the mother returned to Jamshedpur from Chandigarh in August 2022, initially leaving their child in his care. Subsequently, during the investigation of a criminal complaint lodged by the mother, the father handed over the child's custody to her on August 20, 2022, pursuant to the investigating officer's directions.
The child thereafter remained with the mother at Jamshedpur. The father instituted Original Suit No. 829 of 2023 before the Family Court, Jamshedpur, seeking custody under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act. During the proceedings, he also sought visitation rights under Section 12 of the Act. However, by an order dated March 13, 2024, the Family Court dismissed his petition as not maintainable.
The Family Court reasoned that Section 25 presupposed the existence of a legally recognised guardian to whose custody the minor was to be restored. Since the father had not previously been appointed or declared a guardian by a competent court, it held that he ought to have proceeded under Section 7 read with Section 17 of the Act.
Aggrieved, the father approached the High Court. The central question before the High Court was whether a parent seeking custody and consequential visitation rights could maintain a petition under Section 25 without first obtaining a declaration of guardianship under Section 7. Examining the statutory scheme, the Bench distinguished between the purposes of the two provisions.
It noted that Section 7 empowers courts to appoint or declare a guardian, whereas Section 25 provides a remedy where a ward has left or has been removed from the custody of a guardian, subject to the welfare of the minor. The Court observed:
“A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it evident that the jurisdiction contemplated under Sections 7 and 25, though relating to the welfare and custody of a minor, operates in distinct statutory contexts. Section 7 concerns the appointment or declaration of a guardian, whereas Section 25 contemplates the return of a ward to the custody of a guardian in the circumstances specified therein.”
Rejecting the proposition that Section 25 could be invoked only by a court-appointed guardian, the Bench held:
“The Court is of the considered opinion that Section 25 of the Act, 1890 is intended to provide a substantive remedy for restoration or regulation of custody where a ward has left or has been removed from the custody of a guardian. The provision does not, either expressly or by necessary implication, mandate that such guardian must necessarily be a court-appointed guardian.”
The Court also examined the provisions of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, particularly Sections 4 and 6, concerning natural guardianship. It acknowledged that Section 6(a) provides that the custody of a child below five years of age shall ordinarily remain with the mother. However, this provision must be considered alongside the paramount consideration of the child's welfare. The Bench clarified that the mother's status as a natural guardian did not, by itself, extinguish the father's status as a natural guardian or prevent examination of his custody claim under Section 25.
Clarifying when a prior declaration of guardianship may be necessary, the Court observed:
“The decision of the issue would, however, depend upon the nature of controversy involved in a given case. Where the very status of a person as guardian is disputed, or where rival claims requiring adjudication as to guardianship are involved, recourse to Section 7 may become necessary. However, where the applicant approaches the court in the capacity of a natural guardian recognized by law and seeks custody or ancillary reliefs concerning the minor, the petition cannot be rejected at the threshold merely on the ground that no prior declaration under Section 7 has been obtained.”
Applying these principles, the Bench held that the Family Court had erred in dismissing the father's petition solely because he had not obtained a declaration of guardianship under Section 7. The Court also noted that the father's application for visitation rights required consideration in a manner that protected the child's welfare and preserved, to the extent appropriate, his relationship with both parents.
Importantly, the High Court clarified that its decision was confined to the maintainability of the petition and did not determine which parent was entitled to custody. The competing claims and allegations were to be examined independently on their merits, with the child's welfare remaining paramount.
Accordingly, the High Court quashed and set aside the Family Court's order dated March 13, 2024, and directed it to decide the matter independently in accordance with law.
Appearance:
For the Appellant: Mr. Indrajit Sinha, Advocate; Mr. Ajay Kumar Sah, Advocate; Ms. Peeya Bhatia, Advocate
For the Respondent: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate; Mr. K.S. Nanda, Advocate; Mr. Prakhar Harit, Advocate; Mr. Anish Lal, Advocate

