'Delay In Trial Cannot By Itself Override Stringent Bail Conditions Under PMLA': Jharkhand High Court Refuses Bail In 750-Cr Fraud Case
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
21 Nov 2026 6:55 PM IST

The Jharkhand HC has held that prolonged incarceration or delay in trial cannot, by itself, override the stringent bail conditions prescribed under Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA). The Court observed that while the period of custody is a relevant consideration, the seriousness of the alleged offence, its societal impact and the statutory restrictions governing bail must also be taken into account.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad rejected the bail application of Shiva Kumar Deora, who is alleged to be the mastermind behind a syndicate operating through 135 shell companies and generating fraudulent Input Tax Credit (ITC) claims of approximately ₹750 crore.
The case arose from three complaint cases instituted before the Court of Economic Offences, Jamshedpur, alleging the operation of a syndicate involved in creating fake companies and issuing bogus GST invoices without any actual supply of goods or services.
According to the Enforcement Directorate (ED), the syndicate operated across Jharkhand, West Bengal, Delhi and other States, using shell companies registered in the names of dummy directors and proprietors to generate and transfer fraudulent ITC. The prosecution alleged that the accused recruited economically vulnerable persons by offering them jobs carrying salaries of ₹10,000 to ₹15,000 per month. Their identity documents, OTPs and PINs were allegedly used to establish shell companies without their knowledge or consent. The ED further alleged that the petitioner and his accomplices were beneficial owners of 135 shell companies through which fraudulent ITC amounting to approximately ₹750 crore was generated and passed on to various beneficiaries.
An ECIR was registered on September 23, 2024, and the petitioner was arrested on May 8, 2025. His earlier bail application was rejected by the Special PMLA Court on July 15, 2025, and subsequently by the High Court on November 12, 2025. The Supreme Court also dismissed his Special Leave Petition on August 7, 2026.
Following the rejection of another bail application by the Special Court on August 22, 2026, the petitioner again approached the High Court. The petitioner primarily sought bail on the grounds of prolonged incarceration of approximately 18 months, delay in trial, parity with a co-accused who had been granted bail, and his medical condition. Examining the renewed application, the High Court noted that the allegations against the petitioner and the statutory conditions under Section 45 PMLA had already been considered while rejecting his earlier bail application.
The Bench found that no substantial fresh ground or change in circumstances had been established to warrant reconsideration of the earlier decision on merits. On the contention concerning prolonged incarceration and delay in trial, the Court held:
“So far as the issue of period of custody and probable delay in trial as agitated by learned counsel for the petitioner is concerned, it is settled proposition of law which has been settled by the Hon'ble Apex Court that the long incarceration (herein about 18 month) or delay in trial alone cannot be ground to release the petitioner on bail, rather in case of scheduled offences/special offences the seriousness of the matter and the societal impact should be taken in to consideration by the Court concerned while enlarging the petitioner on bail”
The Court emphasised that personal liberty must be balanced against the societal impact of grave economic offences. Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in Tarun Kumar v. Directorate of Enforcement, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1486, the Bench reiterated that the period of custody, although relevant, could not independently override the gravity of the allegations or the twin conditions under Section 45 PMLA.
The Court also noted that the prosecution complaint had been filed within the statutory period, charges had already been framed and the trial was at the stage of recording evidence. Of the 29 proposed prosecution witnesses, one had been partly examined.
On the plea of parity, the petitioner relied on the grant of bail to co-accused Mohit Deora. However, the Court held that parity was not an independent ground for bail and had to be assessed alongside the specific role of the accused, the gravity of the offence and the possibility of interference with the trial. The Bench distinguished the petitioner's alleged role as the principal conspirator and mastermind of the syndicate from that of the co-accused. It also considered the ED's apprehension that witnesses, particularly economically vulnerable persons whose identities had allegedly been used to create shell companies, could be influenced.
The Court separately examined the petitioner's request for bail on medical grounds under the proviso to Section 45(1) PMLA. The petitioner relied on his medical conditions, including Type-II Diabetes Mellitus, hypertension, hypothyroidism and a transverse colon polyp. The Bench held that the medical proviso was discretionary and did not create an automatic entitlement to bail merely because an accused suffered from an illness. It observed:
“The determinative test is whether the medical condition suffered by the person in custody is of such a nature that it cannot be adequately managed or treated within the existing medical facilities available in jail.”
Applying this test, the Court found that the petitioner's ailments were chronic conditions which, prima facie, could be monitored and managed through medical facilities available in custody. The Bench noted that the petitioner had neither alleged nor demonstrated any refusal or inadequacy of treatment by the jail authorities. No expert medical opinion had been produced to establish that his ailments were too severe or complex to be satisfactorily treated in judicial custody.
Consequently, the Court declined to exercise its discretion under the medical proviso to Section 45(1) PMLA. Reiterating that delay in trial was insufficient to justify bail in the circumstances of the case, the Court observed:
“Thus, given the grave nature of the allegations, the sophisticated modus operandi employed to project tainted property as untainted, and the strict statutory framework governing bail under the PMLA, no ground exists for the petitioner to claim the benefit of bail either on merits or on account of delay”
The Bench concluded that the petitioner had failed to establish any exceptional circumstance justifying departure from the earlier order rejecting bail.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the bail application.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner: Mr. Vinay Prakash, Advocate; Mr. Niranjan Kumar, Advocate
For the Opposite Party: Mr. Amit Kumar Das, Senior Advocate; Mr. Saurav Kumar, Advocate

