Aadhaar Card Not Proof Of Age: Karnataka High Court Relies On Post Mortem Report To Determine Deceased's Age In Motor Accident Case

  • Anticipatory Bail Granted To Company CEO Alleged To Have Sublet The Process Of Aadhaar Card Enrollment
    Listen to this Article

    The Karnataka High Court has held that an Aadhaar card cannot be relied upon as proof of age for determining compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act. The Court instead relied on the deceased's postmortem report to ascertain his age and apply the appropriate multiplier for calculating compensation.

    The Court observed that where claimants fail to produce other documents substantiating the deceased's age, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal can rely on the age recorded in the postmortem report.

    Justice KS Bharath Kumar accordingly modified a Tribunal order dated April 4, 2024, enhancing the compensation awarded to the wife, daughter and mother of deceased Shareef from ₹26,73,100 to ₹28,68,000.

    The case arose from a road accident on December 18, 2021, in which Shareef died after the car in which he was travelling collided with a tree due to rash and negligent driving.

    The Tribunal had assessed the deceased's age as 36 years and applied a multiplier of 15 while calculating compensation.

    Challenging the award, the claimants submitted that the deceased's age was recorded as 32 years in the postmortem report, whereas his Aadhaar card indicated that he was 35 years, 7 months and 25 days old on the date of the accident.

    They argued that the Tribunal had wrongly treated the deceased as having completed 36 years of age. According to them, even if the age mentioned in the Aadhaar card was considered, the deceased should have been treated as 35 years old, warranting the application of a multiplier of 16 instead of 15. They further contended that if the Aadhaar card was not accepted as proof of age, the Tribunal ought to have relied on the postmortem report.

    The insurance company, while supporting the Tribunal's award, argued that an Aadhaar card could only be used to establish an individual's identity and could not be treated as proof of age. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Saroj and Others v. IFFCO-TOKIO General Insurance Company and Others, the insurer submitted that the claimants should have been directed to produce acceptable documents to establish the deceased's age.

    The High Court referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Saroj and Others, which held that an Aadhaar card serves as proof of identity and not as proof of age. Accordingly, it held that the age mentioned in Shareef's Aadhaar card could not be relied upon for determining the applicable compensation multiplier.

    The Court then referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Sunita and Others v. Vinod Singh and Others, wherein the postmortem report was recognised as a scientific assessment of the deceased's age that could be relied upon for applying the appropriate multiplier in the absence of contrary material.

    Applying these principles, the High Court observed:

    "The age mentioned in the Aadhar Card of the deceased cannot be treated as proof of age and considering that there is no other document on record serving as proof of age, there is no inhibition to consider the age mentioned in the postmortem report at Ex.P-5 for the purpose of determining the age to apply the relevant and appropriate multiplier."

    The Court also rejected the insurer's contention that the claimants should be directed to produce additional documents establishing the deceased's age.

    "When the claimants do not come forward to produce any documents to substantiate the age of the deceased at the time of accident, the only option available to the Tribunal is to accept the age of the deceased as mentioned in postmortem report," it said.

    Since the postmortem report recorded Shareef's age as 32 years, the Court held that a multiplier of 16 was applicable. It accordingly recalculated the compensation at ₹28,68,000, enhancing the Tribunal's award by approximately ₹1.95 lakh.

    Appearance: Advocate GURUPRASAD B.R for Appellants.

    Advocate B.C. SEETHARAMA RAO for R2.

    Case Title :  SAKEENA & Others AND SADIQ BALANJA & ANRCase Number :  MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.6466 OF 2025
    Next Story