S.14 Hindu Succession Act Doesn't Create Irrebuttable Presumption That Property In Woman's Name Is Self-Acquired: Karnataka High Court

  • S.14 Hindu Succession Act Doesnt Create Irrebuttable Presumption That Property In Womans Name Is Self-Acquired: Karnataka High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Karnataka High Court has held that Section 14(1) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, does not create an irrebuttable presumption that every property purchased in the name of a female member of a Hindu joint family is necessarily her independent acquisition when source of consideration is disputed.

    For context, Section 14(1) provides that a property acquired by a woman would be treated as her absolute property.

    Expounding on the provision, Justice Lalitha Kanneganti said,

    “However, Section 14 does not create an irrebuttable presumption that every property purchased in the name of a female member of a Hindu joint family must necessarily be her independent acquisition. Where the very source of the consideration is disputed, the nature of the acquisition must thus be determined.”

    The court was hearing a plea filed by a purchaser of the property, seeking rejection of a plaint in partition suit concerning the property.

    The dispute arose from a partition and declaration suit instituted by respondents B.V. Srinivas and B.V. Munindra. The plaintiffs contended that although the property was purchased in 1974 in the name of their grandmother (Defendant No. 1), the sale consideration was paid out of the joint family funds.

    They sought a declaration that a subsequent sale deed dated January 24, 1997—executed by their grandmother and their father (Defendant No. 2) in favour of petitioner Thimmesh Prabhu (Defendant No. 6)—was not binding on them.

    The petitioner filed an application under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), seeking rejection of the plaint. However, the application was dismissed. Aggrieved by this, the petitioner approached the High Court.

    Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Marabasappa (D) by LRs. & Ors. Vs. Ningappa (D) by LRs. & Ors, the High Court, said that the respondents must establish the joint family nucleus and show that the nucleus was sufficient to fund such acquisition of property.

    “The plaintiffs cannot succeed merely by asserting that their grandmother purchased the property from joint family funds. They must establish the existence of such funds and their availability at the time of acquisition in 1974… Whether that assertion can be established is a question of proof and cannot be answered by treating the registered sale deed in the grandmother's name as conclusive of the source of acquisition,” the Court said.

    The Court further observed that whether the sale deed amounted to an alienation of the grandmother's separate property or affected joint family interest could not be determined at the stage of considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.

    “However, whether the transaction was an alienation of the grandmother's separate property or an alienation affecting an existing joint family interest remains a matter in dispute. That question cannot be resolved under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC,” the Court said.

    It also said that the question of whether the suit was barred by limitation must be separately examined.

    Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the criminal petition.

    Case Title :  THIMMESH PRABHU VS SRI B.V.SRINIVAS & OTHERSCase Number :  CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO. 902 OF 2025 (IO)
    Next Story