- Home
- /
- High Courts
- /
- Rajasthan High Court
- /
- Man In Live-In Relationship With...
Man In Live-In Relationship With Married Woman Has No Locus To Seek Her Production Through Habeas Corpus: Rajasthan High Court
Nupur Agrawal
20 Nov 2026 11:44 AM IST
The Rajasthan High Court has held that a man claiming to be in a live-in relationship with a married woman cannot seek her production through a habeas corpus petition solely on the basis of an agreement to live together, when her earlier marriage continues to subsist.The Court observed that an agreement opposed to public policy cannot be relied upon to claim a legal right, particularly when...
This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers
Subscribe Premium
INR 1099+GST
Your support helps us to bring you more content at
an affordable subscription scheme !!!
All payment options available
The Rajasthan High Court has held that a man claiming to be in a live-in relationship with a married woman cannot seek her production through a habeas corpus petition solely on the basis of an agreement to live together, when her earlier marriage continues to subsist.
The Court observed that an agreement opposed to public policy cannot be relied upon to claim a legal right, particularly when such an agreement affects the legally enforceable rights of an existing spouse.
“Where a valid marriage continues to subsist, the rights of the existing spouse cannot be disregarded merely because one of the parties has entered into a live-in relationship with another person…The mere fact that two adults have voluntarily entered into an agreement to live together does not, by itself, establish that every such relationship is entitled to recognition as a relationship in the nature of marriage.”
A division bench of Justice Munnuri Laxman and Justice Ashutosh Kumar made the observations while dismissing a habeas corpus petition filed by a man seeking the production of a woman whom he claimed to be his wife on the basis of a live-in relationship agreement. The Court also imposed costs of ₹25,000 on the petitioner.
The Court further observed that where the corpus was residing with either parent, brother or a spouse, at parental or matrimonial home, cogent material was required to be placed on record to establish that the corpus was being detained illegally.
“The nature of the evidence required must be sufficient to justify the issuance of the writ, particularly where the relief sought would entail the removal of the corpus from the custody or control of the person with whom he or she is residing. The nature of such relief may be compared, to some extent, with a suit seeking mandatory injunction, as distinguished from one seeking a mere prohibitory injunction.”
For context, the Court was hearing a habeas corpus writ petition filed by the petitioner for the production of the corpus claiming her to be his wife based on an agreement to be a in a live-in relationship, which allegedly was entered into by them out of their own free will.
It was highlighted by the State that the petitioner had suppressed the material facts that the corpus was already in a subsisting valid marriage and also had a child which was born out of her wedlock.
The state argued that, even though the petitioner was claiming the corpus to be his wife, no such marital status was conferred upon them by law. While opposing the petition, it was submitted that since the agreement to be in live-in relationship was unlawful, immoral and opposed to public policy, it was void ab initio and could not confer locus standi on the petitioner.
Further, the state contended that no evidence was place on record by the petitioner to prove that the corpus was illegally detained by the respondents, and it was a mere assumption on his part.
After hearing the contentions, the Court distinguished between two kinds of live-in relationships. First kind, where neither of the parties were in a subsisting valid marriage and chose to live together without solemnizing their marriage. Such relationship might be regarded as being in the nature of marriage and attracted certain legal rights as recognised in law.
The second kind, where either or both the parties were in valid subsisting marriages with different persons. In this regard, the Court opined that legal recognition given to certain kind of live-in relationships, did not automatically extend to every kind of live-in relationship, including the second kind.
The Court further observed that a relationship founded on an agreement could not override or defeat the legally enforceable rights of an existing spouse, merely by the virtue of an agreement for live-in relationship.
Furthermore, the Court agreed with the contention of the State that no cogent evidence was put forth by the petitioner to indicate that the corpus was illegally detained by her parents or relatives.
“Where the corpus is residing under the care and protection of her parents or husband, cogent and compelling evidence is required to establish that she is being illegally detained.”
Accordingly, the petition was dismissed and a cost of Rs. 25000/- was imposed on the petitioner, payable to Child Secretariat, within 4 weeks.


