'Police Has No Authority To Break Citizen's Bones Or Teeth In Name Of Official Duty': Rajasthan High Court

  • Police Has No Authority To Break Citizens Bones Or Teeth In Name Of Official Duty: Rajasthan High Court

    While reinstating the cognizance taken against police officers for allegedly assaulting the petitioner and his mother during their residential visit in relation to warrant against the petitioner's brother, Rajasthan High Court held that no police officer was vested with the authority to break the bones or teeth of a citizen under the pretext of performing official duty.“The authority...

    While reinstating the cognizance taken against police officers for allegedly assaulting the petitioner and his mother during their residential visit in relation to warrant against the petitioner's brother, Rajasthan High Court held that no police officer was vested with the authority to break the bones or teeth of a citizen under the pretext of performing official duty.

    “The authority to apprehend a person cannot be equated with the authority to assault his family members or inflict injuries upon persons who intervene at the scene. Such conduct, if established, would constitute an abuse of official position rather than an ordinary incident of the lawful execution of a warrant…Physical violence, unless justified by the lawful and reasonable necessities of the situation, cannot be elevated to the status of an official function.”

    The bench of Justice Farjand Ali highlighted the distinction between an act committed in exercise of official authority and committed by abusing such authority, and observed that the fact that an incident occurred during official assignment, or at a place visited by the police in relation to an arrest, could not justify invoking the protection under Section 197 CrPC.

    Section 197 CrPC requires a prior government sanction before a court could take cognizance of an offence committed by a public servant while acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duty.

    The Court held that the act complained of should have a reasonable and direct connection with the discharge of official duty. The expression “while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of official duty” could not be interpreted so broadly to include such acts which were completely disconnected with the lawful exercise of official authority.

    For context, the Court was hearing a petition challenging discharge of respondents by the trial court, who had allegedly assaulted the petitioner and his mother.

    As alleged by the petitioner, on the day of the incident, the respondents arrived at the petitioner's residence to inquire about his brother who was not at home. The conversation got aggressive and the petitioners assaulted the petitioner. When petitioner's mother intervened, she was allegedly struck with a lathi on her face, resulting in a broken teeth.

    When complaint was lodged by the petitioner, the magistrate took cognizance. However, this order was set aside by the trial court and the respondents were discharged, on the ground that since the act, complained of, was performed by the respondents during the discharge of their official duty, sanction under Section 197 was required. This order was challenged.

    After hearing the contentions, the Court held that protection under Section 197 was neither absolute nor automatically attracted merely due to official status of the accused that could provide immunity against every act committed by them during the course of employment.

    The Court opined that the statutory protection was attracted only when the act complained of had a direct nexus with the discharge of official duties of the accused person.

    Reference was made to the Supreme Court case in B. Saha v M.S. Kochar in which it was held,

    “…relevant consideration is not merely whether the public servant had an opportunity to commit the offence by virtue of his office, but whether the act complained of was reasonably connected with the performance of his official functions.”

    The Court clarified that even it was assumed that the initial visit of the respondents to the petitioner's resident was lawful, it could not legitimise every act committed thereafter. The Court observed,

    “It is equally significant that the protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C. cannot be converted into a protective umbrella for acts of gratuitous violence or abuse of official authority. The power to arrest a person, execute a warrant or maintain law and order undoubtedly forms part of the legitimate functions of the police. Nevertheless, such authority does not extend to inflicting punitive or retaliatory physical injuries upon a person.”

    In this background, the Court held that alleged act of inflicting injuries on the petitioner's mother was not automatically protected by Section 197.

    Accordingly, the order of the trial court was set aside, and the cognizance taken the magistrate against the respondents was affirmed. The matter was remanded to the trial court for further proceedings.

    Next Story