Probationary Police Constable Can't Be Dismissed Without Inquiry Unless Reasons For Dispensing With It Are Recorded: Rajasthan High Court

  • Rajasthan HC No Coercive Action Against Meat Shop Owners
    Listen to this Article

    The Rajasthan High Court has held that a probationary police constable cannot be dismissed without a disciplinary inquiry unless the competent authority records reasons in writing explaining why conducting such an inquiry is not reasonably practicable.

    The Court made the observation while setting aside the dismissal of a probationary constable who was accused of bringing a girl to his government residential quarters. It directed his reinstatement with notional benefits.

    Justice Anoop Kumar Dhand observed that the authorities had invoked Rule 19(ii) of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1958, without recording any justification for dispensing with the regular disciplinary procedure.

    The Court noted that the constable was dismissed on allegations of misconduct through a stigmatic order that could adversely affect his future career, without complying with the mandatory requirements of Rule 19(ii).

    The provision permits the disciplinary authority to dispense with the regular inquiry procedure under Rules 16, 17 and 18 only when it is satisfied, for reasons recorded in writing, that following such procedure is not reasonably practicable.

    In the present case, the petitioner was appointed as a constable in January 2025 and was still on probation when allegations emerged that he and another police personnel had brought a girl to his government residential quarters on a motorcycle. The girl's family subsequently lodged a complaint with the police.The petitioner was put under suspension which was followed by his termination under Rule 19, without any inquiry. This order was challenged.

    It was the case of the petitioner that no reasons were assigned by the State for invoking powers under Rule 19 and passing such an order of dismissal.

    On the contrary, the State argued that allegations against the petitioner were of serious misconduct that negatively affected the image and dignity of the police department in the society. Hence, the State was right in invoking the powers under Rule 19 that required no inquiry before petitioner's dismissal.

    The State further argued that since the petitioner was still under probation, inquiry under Rule 16 was not required, and in terms of Rule 38A of the Police Service Rules, 1954, his services could be terminated if not found unsatisfactory.

    After hearing the contentions, the Court perused the relevant provisions and observed,

    “…whenever the authorities concerned are of the view that the provisions contained under Rule 19 of the Rules of 1958 are liable to be invoked, then the mandate contained under the said Rule is required to be followed…In the instant case, no specific reasons have been assigned and a straightaway, the services of the petitioner have been dismissed by making stigmatic remarks against him, which may affect his future service career.”

    In relation to the argument concerning Rule 38A of Police Service Rules, 1954, the Court highlighted that the challenged order was not passed in terms of Rule 38A, but by invoking Rule 19(ii) of the Rules.

    Accordingly, the petition was allowed, and the State was directed to reinstate the petitioner, with the liberty to proceed against him in terms of applicable provisions.

    Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. Ashok Bansal, Adv. with Mr. Ayush Bansal, Adv.; Mr. Pawan Sharma, Adv

    Counsel for Respondents: Mr. Somitra Chaturvedi, Dy.G.C. with Mr. Munendra Singh Fauzdar

    Case Title :  Paramvir v State of Rajasthan & OrsCITATION :  2026 LiveLaw (Raj) 497
    Next Story