Family Courts And High Courts Can't Grant Divorce Solely On Ground Of Irretrievable Breakdown Of Marriage: Telangana High Court

  • Family Courts And High Courts Cant Grant Divorce Solely On Ground Of Irretrievable Breakdown Of Marriage: Telangana High Court

    The Telangana High Court has observed that a High Court or Family Court cannot grant a decree of divorce solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, although the said factor can be considered along with other aspects while deciding an appeal for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.The Division Bench of Justice K. Lakshman and Justice K.Sujana observed thus while allowing...

    The Telangana High Court has observed that a High Court or Family Court cannot grant a decree of divorce solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, although the said factor can be considered along with other aspects while deciding an appeal for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

    The Division Bench of Justice K. Lakshman and Justice K.Sujana observed thus while allowing a Family Court Appeal filed by a husband, challenging the dismissal of his divorce petition, noted as below:

    “…there is no possibility of re-union of the parties. There is strained relation between the parties. They are staying separately since last 20 years. The appellant had filed the aforesaid petition in the year 2013….Family court dismissed the aforesaid OP. The appellant preferred the appeal in the year 2017. Thus, they are staying separately since last 20 years. There is no possibility of re-union. However, neither Family Court nor this Court can grant decree of divorce on the ground of irretrievable break down of marriage. However, the said aspects can be considered along with other aspects while deciding the present appeal….”, the court observed.

    To recap, the appellant-husband, an engineer settled in USA, had sought dissolution of his marriage with the respondent-wife under Section 13(1) (ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. Their marriage was solemnised in February 2002, and a son was born out of the wedlock in 2005. The allegations levelled against the wife by the husband were that she insulted his family and frequently left the matrimonial home without cause, and had a son out of the pre-marital affair. During pregnancy, she left for her home in October 2004, and never returned, it was added.

    According to the husband, he managed to obtain a divorce decree from a Texas court in 2009. The petitioner was then also advised to obtain decree of divorce from the competent Court in India as he got the domicile of India.

    The wife challenged the same on the ground that the husband's family sought additional dowry from her and refused to take her and her son to USA.

    The high court, in appeal, noted that the husband failed to prove the allegations of cruelty. The court also observed that the husband had made serious allegations about the wife having a pre-marital son, but produced no evidence to substantiate the same.

    “…The appellant made serious allegation against the respondent that she has informed him that she had a son through her lover prior to the marriage and that son is also staying with her. However, the appellant failed to prove the same by producing any evidence except making a bald allegation…”, the court added.

    The Court also opined that the husband failed to establish the essential ingredients of desertion, such as factum of separation, animus deserendi, absence of consent, and absence of reasonable cause for leaving the matrimonial home.

    “…The aforesaid facts would reveal that despite conducting mediations/panchayats, the parties have not shown interest to join together. The same is evident from the depositions of the P.Ws.2 and R.W.3….The aforesaid facts would reveal that there is strained relation between the parties. The appellant is staying in USA since last 21 years…”, the Bench observed.

    While the Court did not choose to grant divorce merely on the grounds of cruelty or desertion, it noted the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage as a factor to be considered along with other aspects in the appeal.

    “…though the appellant filed the aforesaid OP against the respondent seeking dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty and desertion, he failed to prove the same by producing cogent evidence…. Even according to the respondent, he left for USA in 2005 and he has filed a petition in USA seeking dissolution of marriage….In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the view that there is no possibility of reunion of the parties...The marriage of the appellant with the respondent…. is dissolved by way of decree of divorce on the condition of the appellant paying an amount of Rs.50,00,000/- (Rupees Fifty Lakhs only) to his son within three months from today, failing which, liberty is granted to the son of the appellant to take steps against the appellant”, the court ordered before parting.

    Sebin James

    Sebin James is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Telangana High Court

    Next Story