Protective Homes Meant For Trafficking Victims Can't Be Used To Detain & Remand Accused: Telangana High Court Issues Directions

  • Telangana High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Telangana High Court has issued a slew of directions to ensure that 'Protective Homes' are meant exclusively for victims and not used as penal detention centres for accused persons.

    The Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda said:

    "Under no circumstances shall a Protective Home meant exclusively for victims be used as a place of penal detention or remand for perpetrators or organisers. Where credible material raises a risk that a person proposed for admission is an exploiter or may endanger other residents, the police and the institution shall immediately place such material before the competent Magistrate for appropriate separate placement and protective orders".

    The court however also said that a person can't be termed as a trafficker, merely based on a FIR or a previous accusation. The court noted that this caveat about presumption of guilt is similar to the label of a 'rescued person' label, which 'would not dispense with the need for a careful risk assessment', the court said further.

    “…Articles 21 and 23 of the Constitution require State authorities to act with due diligence to prevent exploitation, protect affected persons and secure access to justice. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 contemplates rescue, production before the competent Magistrate, inquiry, safe custody and rehabilitation. The procedural safeguards under Sections 16 and 17 must be applied in substance and not as a mere formality…”, the court added.

    The court emphasized that protective homes and corrective institutions perform distinct statutory functions. While placement in a corrective institution is not an automatic consequence of an allegation, the possibility of a perpetrator presenting themselves as a victim requires careful verification, the court opined. If there is failure to realise who is whom, it could possibly expose actual victims to intimidation and manipulation, the court warned.

    “…The possibility of an organiser or perpetrator presenting as a victim requires careful verification…The nature and extent of care and rehabilitation required by victims necessarily differ from the corrective and rehabilitative measures lawfully applicable to perpetrators and organisers. Separate facilities and individual measures must therefore correspond to the legal status, assessed needs and safety requirements of the persons concerned….”, the court clarified.

    The court has hence laid down a laid down a comprehensive framework for police, magistrates, and NGOs:

    • Separate Facilities: The State Government and the Director General of Police (DGP) should be taking steps to establish separate corrective institutions for perpetrators and organisers of crimes. A protective home is meant exclusively for victims. and it shouldn't be be used as a place of penal detention or remand for organisers under any circumstances.
    • Individualized Assessment: Police officers must conduct an individualized assessment of every person at the time of rescue, looking for indicators of threat, deception, debt bondage, or restricted movement. The court clarified that previous involvement in a criminal case does not disentitle a person to protection as a possible victim, but the role of each suspect must be investigated independently in a specific matter.
    • SOP Implementation:The DGP, through the Women Safety Wing, may take steps to operationalize the consolidated Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) dated 26.02.2026, which includes pre-rescue planning and discreet identification of organisers.
    • Judicial Scrutiny-Magistrates should not convert the inquiry under Section 17 of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act to a mechanical exercise. Moreover, police must submit verified antecedents, vulnerability indicators, and the suitability of the proposed shelter before a magistrate passes an order with respect to those produced before it.
    • NGO Protection: The police must communicate with proposed institutions regarding space and safety concerns before seeking placement. An NGO cannot be treated as an indiscriminate custodial facility, merely because it assists rescue operations, the court said further.
    • Pre-rescue planning: It shall include verification of credible information, discreet identification of suspected organisers, recruiters, transporters and exploiters, identification of possible victims, assessment of premises and anticipated risks, and arrangement of trained women officers, independent witnesses, interpreters and child-protection personnel wherever necessary. The source of information and identity of rescued persons shall be kept confidential, the court said further.
    • Post Rescue Monitoring- It shall include monitoring s information on threats, attempts to contact or influence victims, missing persons, renewed exploitation and the need for witness protection. Specific protective steps shall be taken against threats, harassment, manipulation or attempts by organisers to influence or recruit residents during rehabilitation.
    • Maintenance of Information- The concerned department shall maintain a current district-wise roster of legally recognised Protective Homes and other suitable facilities, indicating their authorised functions, capacity, specialised services and contact officers. Before seeking placement, the police shall, as far as practicable, communicate with the proposed institution regarding available space and safety concern, the court said further.
    • Action To Be Taken By Police: The police shall issue clear instructions and public advisories to landlords and owners of premises to exercise due diligence while letting their premises, particularly where there is reason to suspect their use for trafficking, running brothel houses or other unlawful activities. Any verification shall be conducted without discrimination

    In addition to the above, the court also said that Children shall be dealt with under the applicable child-protection laws, and that they should be produced before the competent authority.

    To recap, the court was hearing a writ petition filed by a NGO by the name of Prajwala, which is running a Protective Home. The organisation challenged an order by a Nampally CMM, directing the NGO to admit a woman who was rescued during a raid on a spa. According to the NGO, she was also an accused in a separate human trafficking case.

    According to the organisation, admitting an alleged organiser into a protective home for vulnerable trafficking survivors would emerge as a security risk.

    Before the High Court, the NGO contended that it was forced to admit the accused woman since they couldn't risk contempt, despite her involvement in criminal activities.

    Though the woman was later released to her mother, the petitioner pressed for broader institutional safeguards. The NGO told the court that the practice of treating facilities such as 'Prajwala' as a 'default custodial institution' was dangerous.

    Before parting, the court also directed the police to issue advisories to landlords so that they could exercise due diligence to prevent their premises from being used for trafficking. The court, however, warned that such verification should not lead to discrimination based on sex, occupation, or social background.

    Case Title :  M/s. Prajwala vs. The State of Telangana and othersCase Number :  Writ Petition No. 15506 of 2025
    Sebin James

    Sebin James is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Telangana High Court

    Next Story