Anganwadi Workers With Degree Not Barred From 29% Quota For Supervisors In Kerala: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that Anganwadi Workers possessing a graduate degree are not barred from competing for the 29% quota earmarked for workers with SSLC qualification and 10 years' experience for appointment as Supervisors under the Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS). The Court clarified that the additional 11% earmarked for graduates is only an exclusive channel for them, and does not operate to exclude them from the broader 29% quota. Setting aside the Kerala High Court's contrary interpretation, the Court restored the decision of the Administrative Tribunal.A bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice K. Vinod Chandran held that the 2014 amendment to the Special Rules for the Kerala Social Welfare Subordinate Services, 2010 did not create mutually exclusive quotas between graduate and non-graduate Anganwadi Workers. Instead, the amendment merely enhanced the overall quota for Anganwadi Workers from 29% to 40%, carving out 11% specifically for graduates from the open category quota. The Court emphasised that prior to the amendment, all Anganwadi Workers with SSLC and requisite experience, including graduates, were eligible to apply under the 29% quota, and this position continued even after the amendment.The High Court had ruled that out of the 40% quota reserved for Anganwadi Workers, only 11% was meant for graduates, thereby disentitling them from applying for the remaining 29% quota earmarked for Anganwadi Workers who possessed SSLC qualification and 10 years' experience but did not hold a graduate degree. The case arose out of recruitment to the post of Supervisor under the Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS) in Kerala through the Kerala Public Service Commission. Under the applicable service rules governing the Kerala Social Welfare Subordinate Services, a portion of the vacancies was reserved for Anganwadi Workers. Originally, the recruitment ratio provided 29% quota for Anganwadi Workers who possessed a Secondary School Leaving Certificate (SSLC) and 10 years of experience. After an amendment to the rules effective from January 1, 2014, the overall quota for Anganwadi Workers was increased to 40%, which was further split into 29% for Anganwadi Workers with SSLC and 10 years' experience and 11% specifically for Anganwadi Workers possessing a graduate degree. During the selection process conducted by the Kerala Public Service Commission, several graduate Anganwadi Workers applied and were considered under both the 29% and the 11% quotas. This was challenged by Anganwadi Workers who possessed only SSLC qualification, contending that graduate candidates should be confined only to the 11% quota meant for graduates and should not be permitted to compete for the 29% quota meant for SSLC-qualified workers. The challenge was initially rejected by the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, which upheld the selection process. However, the Kerala High Court reversed the Tribunal's decision and held that the 11% quota for graduates was exclusive, thereby preventing graduate Anganwadi Workers from applying under the 29% quota. Aggrieved by the High Court's ruling, the graduate Anganwadi Workers approached the Supreme Court. Disagreeing with the High Court's decision, the judgment authored by Justice Chandran observed that the 11% quota for graduates was carved out from the general direct recruitment quota and not from the 29% quota available to Anganwadi Workers. “The provision of a ratio of 11% carved out from the direct recruitment quota of open candidates, would be entitled exclusively to graduate Anganwadi Workers with graduation. This does not in any manner reduce the chances of recruitment of Anganwadi Workers having SSLC alone; which ground of reduction of chances in any event is not a valid contention that can be taken by the aspirants to a particular post.”, the court observed. The Court noted that the 29% quota for Anganwadi Workers with SSLC qualification remained unchanged after the amendment, and graduates who also possessed SSLC qualification and the required experience could not be excluded from competing for those posts. “The rules governing the selection and the qualification prescribed enabled the Anganwadi Workers with 10 years' experience and SSLC to compete for the 29% vacancies even if they are graduates and did not exclude them by the amendment.”, the court said. The Court noted that earmarking 11% of the posts for graduate Anganwadi Workers does not negate their right to be considered for the remaining 29% posts. It observed that the separate quota for graduates was introduced to enhance the efficiency of the cadre and cannot be construed as a ground to deny them eligibility for the remaining posts. “The rule making authority, the State, was of the opinion that there should be an earmarked specific ratio for experienced graduates to enhance the efficiency of the cadre and the resultant services offered. The intention of the Government as coming out from...

Anganwadi Workers With Degree Not Barred From 29% Quota For Supervisors In Kerala: Supreme Court

Yash Mittal

Tags