Tax Classification Must Be Based On Form Of Goods At Stage Of Sale & Not Its End Use : Supreme Court

  • Tax Classification Must Be Based On Form Of Goods At Stage Of Sale & Not Its End Use : Supreme Court

    "The tax authorities are bound to look at what is supplied and not at what is the 'end use' of the good," the Court said.

    The Supreme Court has held that goods sold in the form of powder or biscuits cannot be classified as “non-alcoholic drinks and beverages” merely because they may subsequently be mixed with milk or water to prepare a beverage. A bench of Justice Manmohan and Justice Arun Palli considered an issue of whether the goods should be classified based on their end use, that is, the fact that...

    The Supreme Court has held that goods sold in the form of powder or biscuits cannot be classified as “non-alcoholic drinks and beverages” merely because they may subsequently be mixed with milk or water to prepare a beverage.

    A bench of Justice Manmohan and Justice Arun Palli considered an issue of whether the goods should be classified based on their end use, that is, the fact that they could be mixed with milk or water to make a drink, or based on their form when sold.

    Answering the issue, the Court held that for the purpose of tax classification, the form in which goods exist at the time of sale is determinative, and their subsequent use by consumers cannot alter the taxable classification to levy a higher rate of tax on a consumer.

    The case arose after the Revenue considered the Respondent-Cadila Health Care's products 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' to be a beverage, saying that the end use of the powder would be a liquid intake by a consumer, regardless of the original form of the product i.e., powder or biscuit.

    The Revenue urged that the goods are classifiable as 'Non-Alcoholic Drinks and Beverages' falling under Entry 20(ii), Part IV, Schedule II of the M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994, attracting tax at 10%.

    The Respondent, however, contended that the goods, being sold across the counter in the form of powder and biscuit, are exigible to tax at 8% under the residuary entry.

    The Madhya Pradesh High Court, by impugned judgment, upheld the classification of the goods under the residuary entry of Schedule II to the 1994 Act, subjecting them to tax at 8% for the Assessment Year 1997-1998. Aggrieved, the Revenue appealed to the Supreme Court.

    Dismissing the appeal, the judgment authored by Justice Manmohan upheld the impugned order, stating that the taxable event is the act of supply and that the incidence of taxation is determined by the nature of the goods in the form in which they are sold.

    “The tax authorities are bound to levy tax based on the form of the good at the time of sale. The tax authorities are bound to look at what is supplied and not at what is the 'end use' of the good.”, the Court said.

    The Court illustrated the principle by observing that if a protein powder is sold as powder, the tax applicable to powders would apply. On the other hand, if a ready-to-drink beverage such as bottled cold coffee or a packaged protein shake is sold, it would attract the tax applicable to beverages.

    The Court noted that the specific items mentioned alongside “beverages,” i.e., syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences, all denote liquids or liquid preparations.

    According to the Court, the common thread running through these products is that they are liquid substances capable of being bottled, stored and consumed or otherwise utilised in liquid form.

    Therefore, the expression “beverages” could not be interpreted in isolation to include products having a fundamentally different physical form.

    The Revenue had relied upon earlier decisions concerning products such as Rasna, tea and sharbat. In Pioma Industries v. State of Kerala (2008), concerning Rasna, the relevant entry itself contained an explanation specifically including powders, tablets and concentrates used for preparation of non-alcoholic drinks. The Court noted that the legislature was therefore aware that powders could be expressly included within the category of non-alcoholic beverages, but had not adopted such language in the present entry.

    The Court also distinguished its recent decision in Hamdard (Wakf) Laboratories v. Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P. 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 197, observing that the sharbat involved in that case existed in liquid form, unlike the products before the Court. The Court further clarified that the word “including” in a taxing entry cannot automatically be treated as an all-encompassing expression capable of covering every product remotely connected with beverages.

    As a result, the appeal was dismissed.

    Headnote

    Madhya Pradesh Commercial Tax Act, 1994 – Schedule II, Part IV, Entry 20(ii) & Part VII, Entry 1 – M.P. Entry Tax Act, 1976 – Classification of Goods – 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' – Taxable Event & Form at point of sale vs. End Use – Strict Construction of Taxing Statutes – Rule of Ejusdem Generis - The Revenue sought to classify 'GRD Powder' and 'GRD Mix' under Entry 20(ii), Part IV, Schedule II of the 1994 Act ("All kinds of non-alcoholic drinks and beverages including syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences...") at 10%, contending that the consumer is instructed on the packaging to dilute the powder with milk or water to consume it as a beverage - The respondent assessee contended that the goods, being sold across the counter in the form of powder and biscuits, fall under the residuary entry attracting 8% tax - Dismissing the appeals of the Revenue and affirming the High Court's judgment, the Supreme Court held - i. Taxing statutes must be strictly construed: Intention must be gathered strictly from plain, unambiguous statutory text - words cannot be added or implied to alter the statutory scope (Mathuram Agrawal v. State of M.P. followed); ii Form at the time of sale governs taxability, not end use - The taxable event is the supply/sale of the good, and liability is fixed by the physical form of the good at the time of sale - The subsequent use by a consumer (whether diluted into a liquid beverage or used in solid preparations like barfi) cannot retrospectively alter the nature of the taxable supply - Tax authorities must assess what is sold, not what it becomes upon ultimate consumption (CCE v. Carrier Aircon Ltd. and Dunlop India Ltd. v. UOI followed); iii. Application of Ejusdem Generis to Entry 20(ii) - In Entry 20(ii), the term "beverages" is accompanied by words such as "syrups, cordials, distilled juices, ark and essences", all of which share the common characteristic of being liquids or liquid preparations capable of being bottled or corked - Under the rule of ejusdem generis, general expressions must take color from accompanying specific words - 'beverages' cannot be stretched to cover items of an entirely distinct physical form, such as powders or biscuits; iv. Limits of Common Parlance / Functional Tests - Tests of common parlance, functional character, or basic nature cannot be deployed to override explicit statutory guidance or to import the concept of end use when the entry does not specify end use - Goods that do not fit the specific statutory description of an entry must be classified under the residuary entry and cannot be artificially forced into a specific entry merely to fetch higher revenue. [Relied on Mathuram Agrawal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1999) 8 SCC 667; Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi v. Carrier Aircon Ltd., (2006) 5 SCC 596; Distinguished from Pioma Industries v. State of Kerala, (2008) 12 SCC 695; S. Samuel M.D., Harrisons Malayalam v. Union of India, (2004) 1 SCC 256; Paras 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 29]

    Appearance:

    For Appellant(s) : Ms. Mrinal Gopal Elker, AOR Mr. Arkaj Kumar, Adv. Mr. Srajan Yadav, Adv. Mr. Arkaj Kumar Ga, Adv. Mr. Harmeet Singh Ruprah, AOR Mr. Aakarsh Mishra, Adv.

    For Respondent(s) : Mr. Vivek Sarin, Sr. Adv. Mr. Bhargava V. Desai, AOR Ms. Nandita Shinghal, Adv. Mr. Shivam Sharma, Adv. Ms. Prakriti Rastogi, Adv. Ms. Nandita Singhal, Adv. Ms. Surabhi Tuli, Adv.


    Yash Mittal

    Yash Mittal is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Supreme Court of India

    Next Story