Beyond Reactive Policing: Making Situational Crime Prevention An Institutional Duty

  • Beyond Reactive Policing: Making Situational Crime Prevention An Institutional Duty
    Listen to this Article

    The Supreme Court has recently reminded the Delhi Police that “what is important is to prevent the crime, not what you do after the crime is committed.” The observation was made by a Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran in the suo motu case In Re: Recent Rape Incidents in Delhi NCR, registered in September this year after a series of sexual offences against women and minor girls in the region, including the gang rape of a teenager in a public park in south-east Delhi and the sexual assault of a minor in a moving bus. The Court had earlier directed the Delhi Police and civic authorities to map vulnerable areas, increase CCTV coverage, improve street lighting and step up patrolling within four weeks.

    While hearing the matter, the Bench raised a pertinent question about the need for a structured approach to crime prevention in place of the prevailing reactive model of policing. It also emphasised that arresting offenders, however promptly, cannot by itself provide a lasting solution to crime. The observation underscores the need to prioritise proactive safety measures over post-crime investigation. An arrest, however quick, comes after the victim has already suffered the harm.

    Why Are We Not a Preventive Regime?

    Structurally speaking, policing in India was never conceived as a fundamentally preventive institution. Crime prevention has largely remained confined to routine functions such as patrolling, maintaining law and order, and undertaking occasional preventive measures. Historically, policing has been organised primarily around responding to incidents rather than systematically preventing their occurrence. The legal framework governing the police does not provide a comprehensive institutional architecture for crime prevention.

    Section 168 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which corresponds to Section 149 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, provides that every police officer “may interpose for the purpose of preventing, and shall, to the best of his ability, prevent” the commission of any cognizable offence. The duty, however, is placed on the individual officer and arises when an offence is about to be committed. The other provisions of Chapter XII, relating to information of a design to commit an offence, arrest to prevent its commission and prevention of injury to public property, are of the same nature. Prevention, therefore, remains largely a matter of the individual officer's judgement and discretion rather than a systematically organised institutional responsibility. It is neither consistently planned nor evaluated through a dedicated mechanism.

    Meanwhile, several conditions facilitating crime fall within the jurisdiction of institutions other than the police. Municipal corporations maintain streets, parks and public spaces, while transport authorities oversee buses, stations and transport routes. The incidents before the Supreme Court took place in such spaces. Yet these institutions are seldom recognised as integral participants in crime prevention, and questions about safety in public spaces are usually addressed to the police alone.

    While India continues to struggle with preventive solutions, several countries have developed institutional mechanisms and evidence-based approaches for reducing opportunities for crime.

    How Situational Crime Prevention May Help

    Broadly, crime prevention takes two approaches. The first seeks to reduce the motivation to offend, while the second aims to minimise opportunities for committing crime. The former requires long-term social and behavioural interventions and is inherently difficult to achieve. The latter, particularly through Situational Crime Prevention (SCP), developed largely in the work of Ronald Clarke, offers the possibility of tangible outcomes within a shorter period.

    SCP proceeds on the premise that crime becomes more likely when opportunities for offending are readily available. According to the routine activity theory of Lawrence Cohen and Marcus Felson, three conditions must converge for a crime to occur: a motivated offender, a suitable target or victim, and the absence of capable guardianship. In cases of sexual assault, these conditions may converge in poorly monitored or inadequately protected public spaces. The objective of policing should be to make crime more difficult, riskier and less rewarding.

    This requires understanding why certain locations are more vulnerable to crime and how opportunities for offending emerge. Policing must therefore be reimagined to reduce such opportunities while increasing the likelihood of intervention, detection and apprehension. Problem-oriented policing, associated with Herman Goldstein, offers a complementary approach by directing police efforts towards recurring crime patterns, their underlying causes and targeted preventive interventions.

    Hotspot analysis is useful here. Crime is rarely spread evenly across a city. It tends to cluster in a few streets, markets, parks and transit points. Once the police know where these places are, they can do something about them. A dark stretch of road can be lit, a park can be watched, and a bus stop can be made less isolated. The aim is to make the target harder to reach, to raise the chance that someone will notice, and to make the offence less worth the trouble.

    The 'broken windows' approach of James Q. Wilson and George Kelling takes this a step further. Their argument was that visible disorder, when left unattended, tells potential offenders that nobody is in charge, and that this in turn invites more serious crime. The theory has been questioned by researchers, and in some places it has been used to justify heavy-handed policing of petty offences. Even so, the basic point is hard to dismiss: the way public spaces are looked after has a bearing on what happens in them. A streetlight that stays broken for weeks is a civic failure, but it is also a safety problem.

    Several of the measures directed by the Supreme Court, such as mapping vulnerable areas, installing CCTV cameras, improving lighting and increasing patrols, belong to this family of situational measures. The difficulty is that, without an institutional framework, such steps are usually taken in response to a particular incident or a court order, and there is a real risk that they will be allowed to lapse once public attention moves elsewhere.

    Lessons from the UK

    The United Kingdom has gone some distance in turning these ideas into law and practice. Section 17 of the Crime and Disorder Act, 1998 requires local authorities and certain other public bodies, while carrying out their ordinary functions, to have due regard to the likely effect of those functions on crime and disorder and to do all that they reasonably can to prevent them. In other words, a council deciding on street lighting or the layout of a housing estate is expected to ask what that decision means for crime. Crime prevention thus becomes a shared responsibility. The police work with local councils, health and probation services and other agencies through community safety partnerships, which also draw in schools, transport operators and local businesses.

    The UK has also relied heavily on CCTV, crime mapping and the use of data to decide where police resources should go. The College of Policing maintains a Crime Reduction Toolkit, which sets out what the research says about the effectiveness of different interventions, so that local bodies are not left to guess. From 2020 to 2025, the Home Office ran the Safer Streets Fund, under which local areas received money to redesign public spaces, improve lighting, install cameras and take other safety measures, many of them aimed at the safety of women and girls. The Fund has now been discontinued. Its evaluations, however, are still worth reading for what they show about which interventions made a difference and which did not.

    What India Can Learn

    India need not copy the UK model wholesale. What it should take from it is the recognition that the police, acting alone and after the event, cannot bring crime down in any lasting way. How public spaces are designed, maintained and managed has to be part of the preventive effort. This would mean expecting the police to prevent crime and not only respond to it, and being clear about who is responsible for what and how success is to be judged. A statutory obligation on municipal bodies, transport authorities and other public agencies, along the lines of Section 17, would be a sensible place to begin.

    We also need concrete targets. These could include lower crime rates in identified high-risk areas, better lighting and surveillance coverage, and a measurable improvement in how safe women feel in public spaces. Installing cameras or streetlights should not, by itself, be counted as an achievement. What matters is whether these measures have actually made people safer. The proceedings now before the Supreme Court offer an opportunity to ask the authorities for exactly this kind of information, rather than a count of the cameras and lights put up.

    This approach is not intended to substitute investigation, prosecution or punishment. These functions remain indispensable. However, the efficiency of police action after an offence should not remain the principal measure of policing success. The fundamental question must be whether crime is actually being prevented and reduced.

    Ultimately, the measure of effective policing must shift from how efficiently the police react to crime to how successfully the policing system prevents it. The real challenge is to institutionalise prevention as a measurable responsibility of the police and other public agencies, rather than remain confined to responding after the harm has already been done.

    Author is Vice Chancellor, National Law University Delhi. Views are personal.

    Next Story