Electoral Bonds Scheme Unconstitutional : Supreme Court- LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

15 Feb 2024 2:26 AM GMT

  • Electoral Bonds Scheme Unconstitutional : Supreme Court-  LIVE  UPDATES

    A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court will pronounce at 10.30 AM today judgment on the petitions challenging the electoral bonds scheme.A 5-judge bench comprising Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, Justices Sanjiv Khanna, BR Gavai, JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra heard the matter and reserved the verdict on November 2 last year.The petitioners - Association for Democratic Reforms...

    A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court will pronounce at 10.30 AM today judgment on the petitions challenging the electoral bonds scheme.

    A 5-judge bench comprising Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, Justices Sanjiv Khanna, BR Gavai, JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra heard the matter and reserved the verdict on November 2 last year.

    The petitioners - Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), Communist Party of India (Marxist), Dr Jaya Thakur -challenge the amendments introduced by the Finance Act 2017 which paved the way for electoral bonds scheme. According to the petitioners, the anonymity attached to the electoral bonds affects the transparency in political fundings and infringes the voters' right to information. They also contended that the scheme allowed contributions to be made through shell companies

    The Union Government defended the scheme as a method to ensure that 'white' money is used for political funding through proper banking channels. The Government further contended that it was necessary to keep the identity of donors confidential so that they would not face any retribution from political parties.

    During the hearing, the bench raised several pertinent queries to the Central Government about the scheme, flagging its "selective anonymity" and also asked whether it is legalising kickbacks for parties. The bench observed that it was possible for the ruling party to know the identity of the donors, whereas the opposition parties could not get such information. The bench also raised questions about the removal of the condition that companies can only donate a maximum of 7.5% of their net profits to political parties.

    While concluding the hearing, the bench also directed the Election Commission of India to submit to the Court in a sealed cover the details of the contributions received by all political parties through electoral bonds till September 30.

    Follow this page for live updates from the pronouncement.


    Live Updates

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:25 AM GMT

      CJI : Union has been unable to establish the measure adopted in clause 7(4)(1) of the electoral scheme is the least restrictive measure.

      CJI : Amendments to Income Tax Act provision and the Sec 29C of the Representation of Peoples Act are declared to be ultra vires.

      #BREAKING CJI : Electoral bonds scheme has to be struck down as unconstitutional.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:23 AM GMT

      CJI : Right to privacy of political affiliation does not extend to contributions made to influence public policy and applies only to contributions below the threshold.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:22 AM GMT

      CJI: Not all political contributions are made with the intent to alter public policy. Students, daily wagers etc also contribute. To not grant umbrella of privacy to political contributions only because some contributions are made for other purposes is not impermissible.

      CJI: Informational privacy applicable to political contributions too.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:20 AM GMT

      CJI : Financial contributions to political parties are made for two parties - for support to political party, or contribution may be way of quid pro quo.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:19 AM GMT

      CJI : Infringement to the right to information is not justified by the purpose of curbing black money.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:16 AM GMT

      CJI : Financial supports to political parties can lead to quid pro quo arrangement.

      CJI : Electoral bonds scheme is not the only scheme to curb black money. There are other alternatives.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:15 AM GMT

      CJI : Political contributors get access...this access leads to policy making...because of nexus between money and voting...

      #BREAKING Supreme Court holds that anonymous electoral bonds are violative of right to information and Article 19(1)(a)

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:14 AM GMT

      CJI : Political parties are relevant units in the electoral process. Information about funding of political parties is essential for electoral choices.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:13 AM GMT

      CJI : On issue 1- Courts have held citizens have right to hold govt to account. Crucial aspect of expansion of right to information is that it is not confined to state affairs but also includes information necessary for participatory democracy.

    • 15 Feb 2024 5:12 AM GMT

      CJI : Petitions raise following issues (a) Whether amendments are violative of right to information under Article 19(1)(a)

      (b) Whether unlimited corproate funding violates principles of free and fair elections

    Next Story