Hemant Soren's Interim Bail Plea : Live Updates From Supreme Court

Bench re-lists matter for tomorrow

ASG: I'm sorry if I offended by interrupting on occasions. My filter was not working today

J Datta: I think you'll appreciate this...when another counsel starts arguing, he has prepared arguments in his own way...when your turn comes, you can contest

Sibal: Let me come back tomorrow

ASG: It may be after vacations now

Sibal: Ex facie this is cooked up

J Datta: There is a good case on merits. But we have to look at it from a diff perspective. Tomorrow

J Datta: Doesn't the logic in Rahul Modi apply? Here, it's not habeas corpus. But you're in illegal custody. There are judicial orders of cognizance

Sibal: It will have to be said that moment I filed for bail, my challenge to arrest is extinguished 

J Datta: Doesn't the logic in Rahul Modi apply? Here, it's not habeas corpus. But you're in illegal custody. There are judicial orders of cognizance

Sibal: It will have to be said that moment I filed for bail, my challenge to arrest is extinguished 

J Datta: Does the judgment in [...] apply?

Sibal: No, it was a habeas corpus case. HC has distinguished it

ASG gives citation of judgment

Sibal: Please don't interrupt, I am arguing

ASG: Just helping the Court

Sibal: I'm helping court, don't worry

Sibal: I am not saying don't rely on this or that statement. Because HC delayed it, I had to ask for bail

ASG: Ditto arguments were made

Sibal: There is nothing to show Bhanu Prashad shared the property details with Soren.

J Datta: In application, you said arrest should not have been made

Sibal: An offense cannot be made out under PMLA - I did not argue that. I argued that in High Court. Arrest is bad on facts

J Datta: Same arguments were taken earlier when application was filed

Sibal: No