Independence Of Judiciary Is Non-Negotiable: Justice KV Viswanathan

  • Independence Of Judiciary Is Non-Negotiable: Justice KV Viswanathan
    Listen to this Article

    Justice KV Viswanathan of the Supreme Court said that independence of the judiciary is non-negotiable, describing Advocate Akash Vajpai's book Freedom on Trial as a timely reminder of the importance of judicial independence, the rule of law and the sacrifices made by India's freedom fighters.

    Speaking at the launch of the book in New Delhi on Friday, Justice Viswanathan said that the work was not merely a narration of historical trials but carried several important messages, with its primary message being a tribute to the independence of the judiciary.

    Justice Viswanathan observed that the book brought out the consequences of a situation in which the independence of the judiciary was, and the rule of law is imperilled. The protagonists in the historical trials narrated in the book were subjected to tyrannical laws, but the judiciary, despite some judges being remorseful, did not always demonstrate the courage required to stand up to the executive, he noted.

    He identified three important messages emerging from the book: the indispensable importance of judicial independence, the consequences of tyrannical laws for those who enact and enforce them, and the centrality of the rule of law.

    "Independence of judiciary is non-negotiable. Absolutely," he said.

    On the second message, Justice Viswanathan said that tyrannical laws could eventually boomerang on the administration itself. The historical experiences documented in the book demonstrated how attempts by the colonial administration to suppress dissent and exercise arbitrary authority could produce consequences contrary to its intentions.

    "Why should a book about colonial trials matter to us today? These cases show what happens when procedure is bent to suit power. Independent judges, fair hearing and the right to appeal are not technicalities; they are the difference between a system built on justice and the rule of law and a system negating these precepts," he said.

    Referring to the sacrifices made by India's freedom fighters, the Supreme Court judge said that one must appreciate the tremendous personal and professional costs they were willing to bear to secure independence.

    He referred to leaders such as Mahatma Gandhi and Bal Gangadhar Tilak, who gave up comfortable lives, professional pursuits and sources of income to plunge themselves into the freedom struggle.

    "Imagine sacrificing your profession, your income and launching yourself into the freedom struggle," he said.

    "It is time that we rededicate ourselves. This book is a timely reminder that independence and freedom came at a great cost," Justice Viswanathan said.

    He pointed out that the book underscored the importance of a robust and courageous Bar in preserving judicial independence and the rule of law.

    Referring to the historic trials associated with India's freedom movement, he pointed out how lawyers and members of the legal profession played a significant role in challenging colonial authority. The defence mounted during the Indian National Army (INA) trials demonstrated the importance of an assertive Bar.

    He recalled that even Jawaharlal Nehru donned his lawyer's robes to appear in the INA trials, alongside eminent lawyers such as Bhulabhai Desai.

    Justice Viswanathan observed that the INA trials became a significant moment in India's freedom struggle, attracting widespread public scrutiny and generating considerable public anger against the British administration.

    The British attempt to prosecute the INA officers eventually backfired, he said. The trials became a powerful symbol of Hindu-Muslim-Sikh unity, with the courtroom itself emerging as a space where the authority of the colonial state was challenged, and the Crown questioned by advocates.

    Although the outcome of the trials was, in many ways, predetermined by the colonial administration, the proceedings demonstrated how legal advocacy could become a powerful instrument of resistance and public mobilisation.

    He said that these were among the many lessons embedded in Freedom on Trial, making it much more than a historical account of trials conducted during the freedom struggle.

    Next Story