'Industry' Definition Reference : Live Updates From Supreme Court 9-Judge Bench [Day 2]

Hegde: My limited point was in February the bench had a deadline to meet and its thinking had not totally fructified. There were creases that were remained to be ironed out. J Chandrachud indicated we were in brought agreement and when he saw the divergence, he said he agrees with majority.

Hegde: CJ Chandrachud said that he agrees

CJI: their judgments also came in april?

Hegde: there is a dissent of two, CJ Beg concurs, J Chandrachud concurs

J Datta: four were in majority, J Chandrachud was later in majority

CJI: the dissenting opinion also came in april?

Hegde: 7 April 1987, J Chandrachud gave a short order

CJI: that paragraph

Hedge: CJ Beg was retiring so

J Nagarathna: April 1987, J Chandrachud had become the CJI

Hegde: "We will give our reasons later indicating the area of concurrence and divergence, if any, on the various points in controversy on which our learned Brother has dwelt- J Chandrachud had said'

Hegde: yesterday, I was on the point of what was happening on 21 Feb 1978 in Bangalore Water Supply. If I may draw your attention to paragraph 170 of the judgment.

Senior Advocate

to begin arguments.