Justice BV Nagarathna, Who Might Become First Woman Chief Justice Of India, Has Pioneered Social Welfare

The long wait for the first woman Chief Justice of India might find an end with Justice B V Nagarathna, who is in the line to become the CJI in September 2027 as per the seniority list.Her tenure as the CJI will be for only 36 days, if appointments go as per the seniority turn.Justice Nagarathna, daughter of former Chief Justice of India ES Venkataramiah, was enrolled to the Bangalore Bar in 1987. She was appointed as an Additional Judge of the High Court of Karnataka on 18-2-2008 and permanent Judge on 17-02-2010.During her stint as a judge of the Karnataka High Court, she has pioneered the cause of social welfare, ensured the right to education for children and protected the rights of the marginalized. These are apart from her notable judgments interpreting the law in complex issues relating to companies act, civil litigation and criminal trials.Call made for law to protect children in illegitimate marriageShe has been instrumental in upholding and protecting the rights of children. In her judgment dated June 24, 2021, in the case of K Santosha And The Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited she made an appeal to the Parliament to amend the law to protect the rights of children born out of an illegitimate marriage."Of course, it is for the Parliament to legislate on the conferment of legitimacy on children born out of the void or voidable marriages under the personal law other than the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act. But, for the limited purpose of this case, we find that children born out of void and voidable marriages under other personal laws, where there is no provision for conferment of legitimacy, must also have equal protection of the law by treating them on par with children born out of void and voidable marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act or the Special Marriage Act, 1954, insofar as the appointment on compassionate basis is concerned", the judgment stated.She had added "No child is born in this world without a father and a mother. A child has no role to play in his/her birth. Hence, law should recognise the fact that there may be illegitimate parents, but no illegitimate children".Quashing of NLSIU's domicile reservationJustice Nagarathna authored the judgment which quashed the Karnataka amendment which introduced 25% domicile reservation in the National Law School of India University, Bengaluru(Master Balachandar Krishnan v State of Karantaka).In her judgement, Justice Nagarathna said "NLSIU was a unique national institution and cannot be construed to be a State University". Junking the State government's contention that the reservation is intended to ensure that some of the students graduating from the Law School will remain in Karnataka, her judgment had observed:"Moreover, in today's Indian economic ethos, where liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation is the triple mantra, particularly after the reforms in the economy post 1991, it is unfair to expect Karnataka students to remain in and practice in Karnataka only. Their aspirations cannot be confined to Karnataka, when opportunities are available in other parts of India and overseas. They cannot be tied to this State alone, when avenues are available all over India as well as abroad for higher education or for professional work. Therefore, any horizontal reservation provided to students of Karnataka would not advance the State's interest. There is no compulsion for students of Karnataka to remain in the State nor can such a promise be imposed on them for the purpose of fostering the impugned reservation as it would violate their freedom under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution". Pioneering the cause of education of childrenJustice Nagarathna's directions brought out the ugly face of digital-divide which hindered the right to education amid the pandemic.The survey report indicated that 24.50 percent of students do not have access to the technology to attend e-classes. Justice Nagarathna in her order dated July 15, while directing the State government to come out with an action plan to bridge the technological divide, said, "economic backwardness or poverty should not become a reason for lack of continuity in education". Similarly, her concern for providing basic education to students in the rural/remote areas of the state was evident from her order in the case of Anti-Corruption Council of India And The State of Karnataka. In its order dated July 1, the court noted "One of the reasons why children don't like schools is because of the environment there, walls are broken, leakages are there, no water supply, no electricity, etc. especially in rural areas." The court in this matter has called upon certain expert groups to assist in forming a road map for spending the Rs 100 crore budgeted by the government for government/aided school infrastructure in a proper manner. Girl child hygiene and education. Justice Nagarathna has...

Justice BV Nagarathna, Who Might Become First Woman Chief Justice Of India, Has Pioneered Social Welfare

Mustafa Plumber

Tags