Prosthetic Limb Costs Must Also Be Compensated To Restore Accident Victims To Dignified Life: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that compensation awarded to motor accident victims must include the cost of prosthetic limbs and their maintenance, emphasizing that such devices are essential to restoring mobility, confidence, and dignity to amputees.Observing that a prosthetic limb is integral to the life of a person who has lost a limb, the Court underscored that compensation must aim to place the injured person, as far as possible, in the position they would have occupied prior to the accident.A bench of Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice KV Viswanathan, hearing an appeal arising out of a bus accident of 2007, noted that neither the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal nor the High Court had awarded any amount towards prosthetic limb expenses, despite the claimant having suffered amputation of his right leg.The Court emphasized that the mandate under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act is to award “just compensation,” which must be fair, reasonable, and responsive to the actual needs of the injured person.Highlighting the principle of restitutio in integrum, the Court stated that damages should enable the victim to procure necessary aids and equipment required due to the injury.Prosthetic Limb Not A One-Time ExpenseThe Court recognized that prosthetic limbs are not permanent devices and typically require replacement at periodic intervals. It accepted that an artificial limb generally needs replacement once every five years and that maintenance costs must also be factored into compensation.Applying an assumed life expectancy of 70 years and a five-year replacement cycle, the Court calculated that the claimant, who was 32 years old at the time of the accident, would require seven prosthetic limbs during his lifetime.Accordingly, the Court awarded ₹3,00,000 per prosthetic limb and ₹5,00,000 towards maintenance expenses, resulting in a total of ₹26 lakh under the head of prosthetic limb costs.Government Rates Not Binding If They Do Not Meet Reasonable NeedsThe Court rejected the insurer's reliance on government-notified rates that suggested much lower prices for prosthetic devices, holding that compensation must reflect the claimant's reasonable requirements rather than the cheapest available option.It clarified that a claimant is entitled to procure a prosthetic limb from an appropriate private provider if that choice is reasonable in light of their medical and functional needs.The Court followed the 2022 judgment in Mohd. Sabeer @ Shabir Hussain v. Regional Manager, U.P. State Road Transport Corporation in which the cost of prosthetic limb was taken as Rs 3 lakh.BackgroundThe case arose from a 2007 accident in which a Haryana Roadways bus hit the claimant's motorcycle, resulting in amputation of his right leg below the knee. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal had initially awarded ₹8.73 lakh, which was later enhanced to ₹13.02 lakh by the Rajasthan High Court.Allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court enhanced compensation under multiple heads, including loss of future income and litigation expenses, and awarded a consolidated amount of ₹26 lakh towards prosthetic limb cost and maintenance.The Court directed the insurer to pay a total additional amount of ₹36.2 lakh, over and above the compensation awarded by the High Court, within four weeks.Case : Prahlad Sahai v Haryana Roadways and anrCitation : 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 407Click here to read the judgmentAppearances :Adv Anuj Bhandari for the appellant; Adv Akshay Amritanshu Haryana Roadways Corporation; Sr Adv Vishnu Mehra for the Insurance Company

Prosthetic Limb Costs Must Also Be Compensated To Restore Accident Victims To Dignified Life: Supreme Court

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers

INR 1099+GST

Tags

Prosthetic Limb Costs Must Also Be Compensated To Restore Accident Victims To Dignified Life: Supreme Court

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

This is a premium content Available exclusively to Our subscribers

INR 1099+GST

Tags

This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers