Court Must Assess Builder-Banker Nexus Before Directing Loan Recovery From Homebuyer : Supreme Court

  • Court Must Assess Builder-Banker Nexus Before Directing Loan Recovery From Homebuyer : Supreme Court

    It must be assesses if the loan was disbursed strictly in accordance with the tripartite agreement, and recovery must be ordered only if the homebuyer is clearly in default.

    Listen to this Article

    The Supreme Court recently observed that unless homebuyers are clearly found in default, upon examining the loan disbursement mechanism between banks and builders, a competent court cannot pass interim directions against homebuyers regarding payment of instalments.

    A bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana passed the order in a writ petition filed by homebuyers in the 'Krishna Housing Scheme' project at Sohna, Gurugram which was launched by M/s Raheja Developers Limited (private builder-cum-developer).

    Granting protection to the petitioner-homebuyers (or any similarly placed homebuyer) from any coercive action, the order stated,

    "In our considered opinion, it is the bounden duty of the competent Court to first determine the nexus between the builder and the Bank authorities and examine whether the Bank disbursed the loan amount to the builder strictly in terms of the Tripartite Agreement. Unless a categorical finding is returned that the home buyers are in default, no interim direction regarding payment of installments can be issued against them. We, therefore, direct the Civil Court to not take any coercive action against the petitioners or similarly placed home buyers without first deciding the abovementioned issue."

    Briefly put, a Tripartite Agreement was executed between the petitioners, SBI and Raheja Developers regarding the housing loan availed by the petitioners. Allegedly, Raheja Developers failed to honor its commitment under it. Though the loan disbursal was linked to construction progress, SBI made payments to Raheja developers without there being any progress.

    In August 2025, Raheja Developers went into Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process. Before NCLT, it offered to refund the homebuyers' amount in 6 monthly instalments.

    Whilst these proceedings were pending, SBI initiated recovery suits against the petitioner-homebuyers before the Commercial Court, Saket Courts, Delhi. The Court passed interim orders against the homebuyers regarding payment of instalments.

    In this backdrop, the Supreme Court passed the above order without expressing anything on merits.

    Notably, in 2024 as well, the top Court granted similar interim relief to several homebuyers who took loans for housing projects in Delhi-Noida. When these projects got stalled, the Court stayed coercive recovery steps by banks/financial institutions and builders/developers against them. The stay order also applied to cheque dishonor cases.

    Later, the Court expressed serious concern about an alleged nexus between builder-banks in NCR, observing that "poor homebuyers" had been taken to ransom. It indicated that investigation by an SIT/CBI was necessary. Subsequently, the Court called on the CBI to submit a proposal regarding the proposed investigation. Finally, in April last year, the Court directed CBI to register 7 PEs (preliminary enquiries).

    With the Court's permission, the CBI proceeded to register 28 regular cases (which also covered projects outside NCR). On filing of chargesheets, the top Court directed the concerned Metropolitan Magistrate to proceed in accordance with law.

    Appearances : Ms. Avantika Chaudhary, Adv. Mr. Piyush Singh, Adv. Mr. Nitesh Ranjan- 3551, AOR

    Case Title :  Ravi Kumar Jangra and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors.,Case Number :  W.P.(C) No. 1415/2026CITATION :  2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1188
    Debby Jain

    Debby Jain is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Supreme Court of India

    Next Story