Manager's Access To Airbnb Room Cannot Absolve Occupant: Supreme Court Cancels Bail Of Accused In Narcotics Case
Saima Anjum
19 Nov 2026 4:35 PM IST

The Supreme Court recently set aside a Bombay High Court order granting bail to an accused in a narcotics case registered in Goa, holding that the High Court was wrong to infer that the accused had not committed the offence merely because the Airbnb facility's manager had access to the room.
A bench of Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice K Vinod Chandran observed so while hearing the appeal filed by the prosecution against the High Court's order granting bail to the accused (respondent), and directed him to surrender within three weeks.
The respondent was allegedly found in possession of 50.03 grams of cocaine and 15.04 grams of MDMA/Ecstasy, recovered from his Airbnb room in Helen Oasis, Vagator, Goa. A case was subsequently registered at the Anti Narcotic Cell Police Station, North Goa. The prosecution alleged that the accused was first detained from the basement and led to the room. However, he refused to hand over the keys. Thereafter, duplicate keys were obtained from the manager of the facility. A search was conducted in the presence of panch witnesses and manager (one Jerry D'Souza), and was also video recorded.
Before the High Court, the accused pleaded that he was apprehended two days earlier, tortured in the police station and a burn injury was inflicted on his hand. It was also alleged that the contraband was planted after he was taken to the room, and that the manager had sufficient time to plant it while the police detained him. Consequently, the accused was granted bail.
Aggrieved by the High Court's order, the prosecution approached the Supreme Court.
Before the Supreme Court, the appellant (prosecution) argued that the High Court granted bail on the ground that the manager had unhindered access to the room. It was submitted that such a reasoning would mean that no recovery from a hotel or rental facility could be pinned on the occupant, since every hotel keeps an alternate key with the management, which is also used for cleaning when the occupants are absent.
Per contra, the accused (respondent) relied on the counter affidavit to assert that he had been framed, arguing that even on the prosecution's story, he was apprehended from the basement and there was nothing to show that he occupied the concerned room (Room No 106). It was also submitted that the manager held the lease agreement and was in occupation of the premises.
Perusing the submissions, the bench agreed with the prosecution's contention.
“We agree with the learned Counsel for the State that if the reasoning adopted by the High Court is accepted, then any recovery made from a hotel room cannot be pinned on the occupant of the said room.”
It also observed that the counter affidavit demolishes the case set up by the respondent, noting that the FIR and the search warrant show that the Raiding Officer informed his superior about reliable information of narcotic activities by the respondent, who was staying in Room No. 106. Thereafter, the officer obtained permission to conduct a house search and the seal to secure the contraband. It further noted that the seizure report was made in the presence of panch witnesses, which were an Industries Inspector and an LDC, and of the manager.
The bench referred to the medical report which recorded a burn injury on the forearm stated to have been caused by a lighter, though the exact age of the injury could not be determined, the doctor opined that it could have occurred two days earlier. On this, it observed as under:
“There was nothing stated by the respondent as to the injury having been inflicted by the police and the entire story set up of an arrest two days back, plant of the narcotics in the room and a bogus raid conducted prima facie does not impress us.”
With regards to the occupancy of the room, the bench examined the Leave and License Agreement and found as follows:
“The lease agreement though shows the facility having been leased out by Mr. Jerry D'Souza, the specific contention of the police as corroborated by the Statement of Mr. Jerry D'Souza is that he had rented out the premises to the petitioner from 17.01.2025 to 26.01.2025. It is within the period of the said renting out and also within the license period that the apprehension and recovery of contraband was made from the premises.”
Applying the aforesaid, the bench set aside High Court's order and directed the respondent to surrender within three weeks.
“We find absolutely no reason to sustain the order granting bail and set aside the order passed by the High Court impugned herein. We direct the respondent to surrender within a period of three weeks from today, failing which the respondent shall be apprehended and produced before the jurisdictional court for taking the said person into judicial custody, subject only to the orders passed by the said court for custody of police, if so required.”
Appearances:
For Appellant: Mr. Omkar Jayant Deshpande, AOR
For Respondent: Ms. Sana Raees Khan, Adv.; Mr. Pranay Shridhar Chitale, AOR; Mr. Aditya Dutta, Adv.

