Supreme Court Hearing On Suo Motu COVID Case: LIVE UPDATES

Radhika Roy

31 May 2021 5:49 AM GMT

  • Supreme Court Hearing On Suo Motu COVID Case: LIVE UPDATES

    A 3-Judge Bench comprising Justices DY Chandrachud, L. Nageswara Rao and S. Ravindra Bhat has resumed the hearing today the suo moto case on COVID issues (In Re Distribution of Essential Services and Supplies During Pandemic). The hearing was deferred until further notice on May 13 after Justice D Y Chandrachud, the Presiding Judge, tested positive for COVID-19.On April 30, the Bench had...

    A 3-Judge Bench comprising Justices DY Chandrachud, L. Nageswara Rao and S. Ravindra Bhat has resumed the hearing today the suo moto case on COVID issues (In Re Distribution of Essential Services and Supplies During Pandemic). 

    The hearing was deferred until further notice on May 13 after Justice D Y Chandrachud, the Presiding Judge, tested positive for COVID-19.

    On April 30, the Bench had raised queries regarding the Centre's vaccination policy, distribution of essential medicines and oxygen allocation to states, making an observation that the vaccination policy was detrimental to the right to health of citizens and required a revisit.

    In response, the Centre filed an Affidavit, saying that its vaccination policy was formulated on the basis of widespread consultations with experts and stakeholders, and was therefore conforming with Articles 14 and 21.


    Live Updates

    • 31 May 2021 7:23 AM GMT

      Singh: The Affidavit says that the different policy is not an issue because every State is willing to pay. That is not an answer. The money will come from public exchequer. This is something that has to be understood.

      #SupremeCourtofIndia #COVID19

    • 31 May 2021 7:22 AM GMT

      Sr. Adv. Vikas Singh appears for Bar Association: We have started vaccination for both the age groups. The problem which arose was that we wanted the doses to be given at 150, they were not willing to give that and we had to get it at a private rate of 600.

    • 31 May 2021 7:21 AM GMT

      Justice Bhat: The only issue that we’re seeing is that vaccination policy. The dialogue will continue. If you change the policy, well.

      SG: If it has to be changed for the better, the government will not oppose that.

      #SupremeCourtofIndia #COVID19

    • 31 May 2021 7:20 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: The idea is not to criticise or pull down anybody. When the EAM went to the US and entered into the dialogue, it showed the importance of the situation.

      SG: The PM has also interacted with many.

      #SupremeCourtofIndia #COVID19

    • 31 May 2021 7:18 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: The purpose of this hearing is dialogic. The purpose is to create dialogues so that the voices of others can be heard.

    • 31 May 2021 7:17 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: Let me tell you from my experience as a Judge - the ability to say that you’re wrong is not a sign of weakness, but a sign of strength.

    • 31 May 2021 7:17 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: We make one appeal to you. Please make sure is your policy is flexible.

      SG: There is no policy which is cast in stone. The situation is dynamic. This is our wisdom.

    • 31 May 2021 7:16 AM GMT

      Arora: Today’s thing was into the vaccine, so I didn’t go into third wave.

      Justice Chandrachud: We will take this next time.

      SG: We have disturbed you more than we should have.

      Justice Chandrachud: My health is subordinate to the welfare of the citizens.

    • 31 May 2021 7:15 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: We would also like the policy to be amended. We want an enforceable policy that can be applied across the country. The policy should be clear cut and dealing with issues. If new issues arrive, then it should be amended.

    • 31 May 2021 7:14 AM GMT

      Justice Chandrachud: Absence of guidelines and policy will only lead to ad hoc decisions being taken across the country. You have to set a policy and formulate what should be done across the country.

    Next Story