Supreme Court's Handbook On Persons With Disabilities Debunks Stereotype-Perpetuating Terms, Advises Judges To Avoid Dehumanising Language

The Chief Justice of India Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud on Saturday(September 28) launched the 'Handbook Concerning Persons with Disabilities' of the Supreme Court of India at the 9th Annual National Consultation Stakeholders Consultation on 'Protecting the Rights of Children Living with Disability and Intersectionality of Disabilities' organised by the Juvenile Justice Committee, Supreme Court of India and in association with UNICEF India.Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Chairman of the Juvenile Justice Committee, who spoke at the event, referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court on disability rights which states: "Language that individualises the impairment and overlooks the disabling social barriers (e.g. terms such as “afflicted”, “suffering”, and “victim”) should be avoided or adequately flagged as contrary to the social model.'The handbook prepared under the guise of Justice Nagarathna under Part II has dedicated an entire chapter titled 'Language And Disabilities'. The handbook states: "The language used by judges in their judgments carries immense weight and has the power to shape societal perceptions and attitudes. When it comes to addressing matters involving persons with disabilities, the use of sensitive language is of paramount importance. Judges must be mindful of avoiding dehumanising or demeaning terminology that perpetuates stigma and reinforces negative stereotypes."This is in line with what Justice Nagarathna stated in her opening address. She said: "Children with disability can face stigma along with negative attitudes that place them at increased risk of violence, neglect abuse and exploitation. Violent forms of discipline can also be given by prevailing attitude towards disability."Don't use stereotype-perpetuating terms: HandbookThe handbook has suggested that no offensive terms such as "crippled," "idiot," “loony,” “mad,” “junkie,” and “retard” should not be used in any derogatory contexts. Some terms such as “people of determination,” “special,” and “differently abled” are also considered condescending and offensive because they stigmatise the language around disability by substituting itIt states that some term terms that must be avoided while referring to persons with disabilities are: Infirm; Stunted; Unfit; Helpless; Crippled; Defected; Deformed; Invalid; Lame; Maimed; Mutilated; or Subnormal.Some key terms to avoid when referring to persons with intellectual or learning disabilities or mental health conditions are: Crazy; Freak; Idiot; Insane; Loony; Mad; Maniac; Nut Case; Nuts; Nutter; Psycho; Simpleton; Stupid; or Unhinged."When it comes to addressing matters involving persons with disabilities, the use of sensitive language is of paramount importance. Judges must be mindful of avoiding dehumanising or demeaning terminology that perpetuates stigma and reinforces negative stereotypes," the Handbook stated.Alternative language to be used for persons with disabilities: People-first approach The handbook states that 'people-first approach' rather than 'identity-first approach' should be employed for persons with disabilities. For instance, 'persons with a disability' is a people-first approach where the individual is recognised and prioritised before the disability. Examples:'persons with a hearing disability' as opposed to 'hearing disabled person'. This is in line with the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 in consonance with United Nations Convention on Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006.Alternatively, the handbook suggests that some individuals may prefer or find acceptable an identify-first approach that puts disability first in the description. For instance, 'blind person' instead of 'person with blindness'.If that is the case, the handbook suggests that when in doubt, best to ask individuals how they wish to identify.The handbook gives a list of 36 stereotype-perpetuating words and their alternative languages. Some of them are:1. Abled-bodied/Normal/of sound body and/or mind/typical/whole: persons without disabilities2. Abnormal atypical: persons with disability or persons with condition/impairment3. Afflicted by/burdened by/suffering from/stricken by/troubled by/victim of: persons with a disability/condition/impairment; The person has [a disability/condition/impairment]/Person experiences [a disability/condition/impairment].4. Differently-abled: person with disability/person with [type of condition/impairment].5. Disabled washroom/handicapped washroom: Accessible washroom 6. Trauma victim: Trauma survivor/ victim (depending on preference)7. Addict: Person with a substance abuse addiction or condition 8. Alcoholic: Person with an alcohol addiction9. Crazy/ Insane/Demented/Deranged/Lunatic/Mental/Senile/Unstable/Psychotic: Person with a mental health condition/Person experiencing a mental health condition/Person who has dementia/Alzheimer's disease, or any other clinical condition (where supported by a clinical diagnosis).10. Inmates or prisoners (of a psychiatric...

Supreme Court's Handbook On Persons With Disabilities Debunks Stereotype-Perpetuating Terms, Advises Judges To Avoid Dehumanising Language

Gursimran Kaur Bakshi

Tags