Arbitration

Why Indian Government Losing Faith In Arbitration?
On 03.06.2024, Government of India, Ministry of Finance, issued an Office Memorandum[1] which send “shock waves” to certain portion of legal community engaged in arbitration. The OM, in a nutshell, mentioned that:1. None of the advantages that arbitration was expected to provide-Speed, Convenience, Technical Expertise, and Finality, were being achieved. Arbitration had simply become an additional layer and source of more litigation. 2. Government as a disputant is subject to large number of...

Beyond Winner And Loser: Reimagining Section 9 In Post-Award Stage
An arbitral award is understood as the culmination of the arbitral process. The pleadings have been closed, evidence has been led and arguments have been heard before rendering an award. The award, however, often marks not the end of the dispute, but the beginning of a distinct post-award phase. The unsuccessful party may challenge the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 ("Arbitration Act"), while the successful party may move towards enforcement. Between the...

Composite Transaction Route To “Veritable Party”: Doctrine Still Finding Its Edges
Indian arbitration law has spent the last two years refining a single question when can a non-signatory be forced into or allowed to invoke an arbitration clause it never signed? The Constitution Bench in Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP India Pvt. Ltd. 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 1042, gave courts two distinct routes to answer this “group of companies” doctrine, which looks at corporate structure and conduct and the “composite transaction” doctrine which looks at whether a set of linked agreements forms a...

Arbitration Clause In One Agreement Can Bind Party To Another Instrument Forming Part Of Composite Transaction: Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has held that where parties structure a single transaction through several interconnected instruments, an arbitration clause contained in one instrument can bind a party through another instrument that is expressly integrated with it, even if the latter instrument does not itself contain an arbitration clause. A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice...

Institutionalizing Trust: Role Of Arbitration Council Of India
In lieu of the writ petition filed by the Anil Kalyandas Thanvi, the Supreme Court of India has sought a response from the Central Government regarding the establishment of an Arbitration Council of India (ACI). Although the provision for the establishment of said Council is provided for by the 2019 Amendment to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, six years have passed without any affirmative action in this direction. The petition draws our attention to the lapses and issues that exist...

When Can High Court Invoke Article 227 Against Arbitral Tribunal?
The Recurring QuestionOne question has consistently tested the boundaries of judicial intervention in arbitration, namely, whether a party dissatisfied with an order of an Arbitral Tribunal, typically one rejecting a jurisdictional objection under Section 16 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (herein after referred to as “the Act”), run to the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution instead of waiting for the final award? The Supreme Court has answered this question...

Can Pre-Deposit Be Mandated To Invoke Arbitration? Supreme Court Refers To Larger Bench, Doubts 2009 Precedent
The Supreme Court on Monday (August 17) referred the question to a larger Bench as to whether pre-deposit conditions in arbitration clauses, requiring contractors to deposit a percentage of the claim amount before invoking arbitration, are valid. A bench of Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Manmohan expressed doubt about the binding nature of the three-judge Bench decision in S.K. Jain v....

Former SC Judge Moves Supreme Court Against Rajasthan HC Calling Tribunal Headed By Him 'Lethargic', Reducing Arbitral Fee
Former Supreme Court judge-Justice Deepak Verma has approached the Supreme Court against a Rajasthan High Court order which criticized a Arbitral Tribunal headed by him as "lethargic".For context, a Single Judge of the High Court passed an order on May 27 directing a 5% cut in the arbitral fees already paid, observing a lack of procedural discipline in the arbitration and defeat of...

Arbitration | Post-Award Section 9 Application By Unsuccessful Party Maintainable In Exceptional Cases : Supreme Court
The Supreme Court on Tuesday (August 11) held that to prevent an award holder's enrichment of a bank guarantee while an award was under challenge, an interim relief under Section 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 can be extended on an award debtor's application to preserve the efficacy of the challenge in Section 34. A bench of Justice KV Viswanathan and Justice Alok...

Arbitration | Involvement In Performance Of Underlying Contract A Factor To Decide If Non-Signatory Bound By Agreement : Supreme Court
The Supreme Court on Wednesday (August 5) held that the involvement of a non-signatory in the performance of the contract would be a factor to consider if they would be bound by the arbitration agreement.“…the participation of a non-signatory in the performance of the underlying contract is the most important factor to be considered as the conduct of the non-signatory parties is an...

Why Meaningful Costs Adjudication Is Essential For Promoting Arbitration In India
Indian courts continue to grapple with an enormous and ever-increasing docket of cases. India's economic aspirations and its ambition to remain one of the world's fastest-growing economies are inextricably linked to the existence of a robust, efficient and credible dispute resolution framework. Investors and entrepreneurs, whether domestic or foreign, seek assurance that commercial disputes, will be resolved fairly, expeditiously and at a reasonable cost. The only viable alternative forum which...

Not Every Procedural Irregularity Vitiates An Arbitral Award: Allahabad High Court
The Allahabad High Court at Lucknow has recently held that not every procedural irregularity would vitiate an arbitral award or justify interference under Sections 34 or 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. A Division Bench of Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Jaspreet Singh made the ruling in a dispute between the U.P. State Highways Authority and the...
