J Amanullah: its a permanent disqualified just on the basis of something which I have no control in future and i can't change my position, even if I want to.

Giri: if its merely birth, it constitutes a disqualification for a person to become an archaka, then in my respectful submission, that would be wrong and that would be invalid.

J Sundresh: that will come under article 25(2)(b)-social reform