Land Acquisition Authority Can't Review Its Own Compensation Award Under National Highways Act: Allahabad High Court

  • Allahabad High Court, Compassionate Appointment Not, Bonanza, Cant Claim, Matter Of Right, Justice Surya Prakash Kesarwani, Justice Jayant Banerji,
    Listen to this Article

    The Allahabad High Court has held that the Competent Authority under the National Highways Act, 1956 cannot review the compensation it has determined under Section 3-G(1) and substitute a fresh figure by a second supplementary award.

    A party dissatisfied with the amount must approach the Arbitrator under Section 3-G(5) of the Act.

    The bench of Justice Siddhartha Varma and Justice Kunal Ravi Singh held,

    “Nothing in Section 3-G, or elsewhere in the Act, 1956, allows the Competent Authority to reopen its own award, re-verify the valuation and substitute a new figure. Had the Legislature wished to give that power, it would have said so. Providing a statutory forum for correcting the quantum points the other way.”

    Land in Village Mawai, District Kaushambi was acquired for the four-lane National Highway No.731A (Ram Van Gaman Marg). After the Executive Engineer, Public Works Department and the Tehsildar verified the valuation of the structures on it, a supplementary award dated 04.08.2023 under Section 3-G(1) determined compensation of Rs.68,00,650.78 for the petitioner's constructions.

    The petitioner was asked on 11.03.2024 to furnish documents for release of the amount. Instead of releasing it, the respondents carried out a fresh verification and passed a second supplementary award dated 14.08.2024 determining Rs.17,79,056/- for the same structures. Rs.29,18,284/- was credited to his account, nothing was paid under the earlier award, and his representation dated 14.07.2025 remained undecided.

    Petitioner contended that the Competent Authority became functus officio once it had determined compensation under Section 3-G(1).

    Standing Counsel for the State and counsel for the National Highways Authority of India could not point to any provision of the Act permitting the review.

    The Court observed that the Competent Authority is a statutory authority holding only the powers the Act gives it, and that the Act itself lays down how an award is to be tested by an Arbitrator appointed under Section 3-G(5).

    Relying on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Patel Narshi Thakershi v. Pradyumansinghji Arjunsinghji and Kalabharati Advertising v. Hemant Vimalnath Narichania, and on the Full Bench decision of the Court in Shivraji v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Allahabad, it held that the power of review is not inherent and exists only where a statute confers it.

    The second award, the Court held, could not be treated as the correction of a clerical or arithmetical slip, resting as it did on a fresh verification of valuation.

    “Re-assessing the value of the structures is exactly the kind of dispute on quantum that the Act, 1956 sends to the Arbitrator. The Competent Authority cannot sit in appeal over its own award.”

    Allowing the writ petition, the Court quashed the award dated 14.08.2024 insofar as it related to the petitioner and directed release of the compensation determined by the award dated 04.08.2023, after adjusting Rs.29,18,284/- already paid, within one month of production of a certified copy of the order. The remedy before the Arbitrator was left open to any party dissatisfied with the quantum.

    Case Title :  Vasudev v. Executive Engineer, Highway Division, Public Work Department, Prayagraj and 2 others
    Next Story