Private Practice By Govt Doctors Affects Larger Public Interest: Allahabad High Court Asks UP Govt To Enforce Restriction Rules
Sparsh Upadhyay
18 Nov 2026 2:59 PM IST

The Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench) has directed the Uttar Pradesh Government's Health Department to take appropriate steps to prevent government doctors from engaging in private practice in violation of the 1983 Rules.
The Court also clarified that such malpractice, which affects the larger public interest, can be challenged through a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) plea.
A bench of Justice Rajan Roy and Justice Manjive Shukla thus rejected the National Health Mission's objection that the PIL plea was not maintainable as the reliefs sought pertained to the service conditions of doctors.
The Court observed that if government doctors are prohibited from private practice under the applicable rules and their engagement in such practice affects the larger public interest, a PIL would certainly be maintainable.
"Probably the subject matter and purport of the writ petition has not been appropriately understood," the Court remarked while rejecting the objection.
It further observed that the question the National Health Mission should have asked itself was "whether the malpractice exists and if so, who is responsible for curing it" rather than raising a technical objection which was unfounded in law.
Against this backdrop, the Court directed the Director General, Medical Health and Family Welfare, Govt of Uttar Pradesh, to look into the matter and take all appropriate steps to prevent private practice by government doctors in violation of the Uttar Pradesh Government Doctors (Allopathic) Restriction on Private Practice Rules, 1983.
For context, the Court was dealing with a PIL plea filed by Ankur Mishr alleging large-scale malpractice by government doctors who were allegedly engaging in private practice in violation of the applicable rules.
The petition was moved against the backdrop of an incident involving the death of a man at a government health facility in Balrampur while he was in police custody.
According to the allegations, instead of being provided immediate and proper medical treatment, he was allegedly locked in a room at the Community Health Centre, Tulsipur.
Despite repeatedly crying for help, he was allegedly not provided any medical attention as the doctors were not available, due to which he died within a few hours.
The Court was apprised by the State's counsel that disciplinary proceedings had been initiated against some doctors in 2025 and that some of them had been suspended. The Court directed that the outcome of those proceedings be brought on record.
Furthermore, the Court directed that enforcement of 1983 rules cannot be treated as a one-time exercise and that the same must be a continuing exercise to monitor the implementation of Rule 3 of the 1983 Rules.
"Let such an exercise be conducted by opposite party no.2 in District-Balrampur," it directed.
The High Court also directed the Director General, Medical Health and Family Welfare, to conduct a specific inquiry into the death of the person at CHC, Tulsipur, Balrampur and submit a report by the next date.
Clarifying the nature of the inquiry, the Court stated that it would be a fact-finding exercise and that, if any illegalities were found on its basis, further action would have to be referred to the competent authority.
The matter has been listed for further hearing on December 21.

