Calcutta High Court Confirms Death Sentence Of Man For Rape And Murder Of 5-Year-Old Girl
Srinjoy Das
17 Nov 2026 7:24 PM IST

The Calcutta High Court has confirmed the death sentence awarded to Ashok Singh for raping and murdering a five-year-old girl in Hooghly in November 2024, rejecting his appeal against conviction and sentence.
A Division Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray, in its judgment dated November 17, upheld the death penalty imposed by the Exclusive POCSO Court, Chinsurah, in January 2025.
The Court also directed the West Bengal Government to increase the victim compensation payable to the deceased child's parents from Rs. 10 lakh to Rs. 15 lakh, observing that the family had not received even the original compensation amount despite the State seeking capital punishment for the convict.
The Bench confirmed the death sentence in the State's death reference (DR 2 of 2025) and dismissed Singh's criminal appeal (CRA (DB) 328 of 2025).
The High Court directed the State to pay the enhanced compensation within two months and submit a compliance report by January 30, 2027.
Background
The prosecution case was that the victim and Singh lived in the same neighbourhood. On November 24, 2024, the girl, aged approximately five years and ten months, went missing from her house.
During the search, her parents and neighbours entered Singh's house and found her lying unconscious on a blanket on the floor, covered with a mosquito net. She was naked and bleeding from her private parts. Her clothes were lying nearby.
The girl was taken to Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital, where she was declared dead.
The prosecution relied on the testimony of a neighbour who stated that she had seen Singh take the child to his house on the pretext of giving her chocolates. The forensic examination also detected Singh's DNA in swabs collected from the victim's genital region.
The post-mortem examination revealed injuries indicating forceful penetration of the vagina and anus, besides serious head injuries. The post-mortem doctor opined that death was caused by intracranial haemorrhage associated with recent forceful penetration and that the manner of death was homicidal.
The trial court convicted Singh under various provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and the POCSO Act, 2012, and imposed the death sentence for the offences of rape and murder.
Before the High Court, Singh argued that the conviction rested entirely on circumstantial evidence and that the prosecution had failed to establish an unbroken chain of circumstances pointing exclusively to his guilt.
His counsel questioned the reliability of the neighbour who claimed to have seen him take the child to his house, pointing out that she had not disclosed this fact to the police or the Magistrate during investigation.
The defence also argued that the trial court had imposed the death penalty without adequately considering mitigating circumstances, the possibility of reformation and rehabilitation, or the alternative of life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life.
The State, however, submitted that the victim was last seen with Singh, her body was recovered from his room and the forensic and medical evidence conclusively established his involvement.
The High Court examined the principles governing capital punishment laid down by the Supreme Court in *Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab* and subsequent decisions.
The Bench observed that even where a case falls within the category of rarest of rare cases, the Court must examine whether the convict could be reformed or rehabilitated before imposing the death penalty.
After examining the circumstances of the crime as well as those of the convict, the High Court affirmed the trial court's judgment of conviction and order of sentence.
It accordingly confirmed the death reference and dismissed Singh's appeal.
The High Court expressed concern that the victim's parents had not received the Rs. 10 lakh compensation earlier directed to be paid to them.
Observing that it was unfortunate that the State was seeking capital punishment for the convict while failing to comply with the direction for payment of compensation to the victim's family, the Court enhanced the amount to Rs. 15 lakh.
The State was directed to ensure payment within two months and submit a compliance report by January 30, 2027.
The Court also directed the Registrar General to send a copy of the judgment to Singh through the Superintendent of the concerned correctional home, informing him of his right to appeal before the Supreme Court and avail free legal aid.
While considering whether Singh could be reformed or rehabilitated, the High Court examined his medical and psychological assessments as well as a report submitted by the Probation Officer.
The Court noted that Singh was approximately 45 years old, illiterate and had no family at present. The medical assessments did not indicate any mental illness or psychological disorder.
The Court also considered evidence concerning his alleged inappropriate conduct towards other minor girls in the neighbourhood, as recorded in statements of two prosecution witnesses before the Magistrate.
It observed that Singh had shown no remorse or repentance during his examination under Section 313 CrPC, despite the forensic evidence linking him to the crime.
The judgment observed:
"The attitude of the convict shows that criminal instinct is embedded in his mind set and he always considered that he did nothing wrong with the child although the said child was raped, murdered and her private parts contained his semen."
The Court concluded that there was no possibility of his reformation.
It also considered the trauma suffered by the victim's parents, noting that the victim's mother had broken down while deposing before the trial court, on one occasion fainting during the recording of her testimony.
The Court observed that the suffering of the victim's family could not be overlooked while determining an appropriate sentence.
"Having carefully weighed the daily agony, enduring anguish, and unyielding grief of the victim's parents alongwith the gravity of the crime, this Court finds no legal or factual infirmity to warrant any interference with the judgment and sentence of punishment inflicted by the learned Trial Court," the judgment stated.
The High Court consequently confirmed the death sentence.
Case: State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh*, DR 2 of 2025 with CRA (DB) 328 of 2025.

