'Delay Defeats Equity': Calcutta High Court Declines Relief In Plea Against Customs' Seizure Of ₹30 Lakh Cash At Kolkata Airport In 2020

  • Delay Defeats Equity: Calcutta High Court Declines Relief In Plea Against Customs Seizure Of ₹30 Lakh Cash At Kolkata Airport In 2020
    Listen to this Article

    The Calcutta High Court has disposed of a writ petition filed by a man challenging Customs adjudication proceedings concerning the seizure of ₹30 lakh in cash while he was travelling from Kolkata to Dhaka in January 2020, observing that his challenge suffered from delay and laches.

    Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee held that whether the Customs authorities had actually served all ten pages of the adjudication order upon the petitioner was a disputed question of fact which could not be determined in exercise of writ jurisdiction.

    The Court observed that the petitioner had failed to raise his objection within a reasonable time despite being informed in December 2023 that the adjudication order had been dispatched to the address mentioned in his passport.

    "It is well-settled that delay and laches defeat equity," the Court observed.

    The petitioner, Sanjib Kumar Chatterjee @ Sanjeev Kumar Chatterjee, had approached the High Court challenging the adjudication proceedings initiated by the Customs authorities following the seizure of ₹30 lakh in Indian currency at Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport on January 22, 2020.

    According to the petition, the cash was allegedly concealed inside his bag when he was travelling from Kolkata to Dhaka. Customs officials seized the amount and subsequently issued a show-cause notice dated September 4, 2020, under Section 124 of the Customs Act, 1962.

    The petitioner submitted his reply to the show-cause notice on November 19, 2020. Thereafter, he was directed to attend a hearing scheduled for July 5, 2021.

    The Joint Commissioner of Customs passed an adjudication order on February 17, 2022. The Customs authorities subsequently informed the petitioner, through a letter dated December 5, 2023, that the adjudication order had been dispatched on February 18, 2022, to the address mentioned in his passport.

    However, the petitioner claimed that he had received only the first page of the adjudication order and that the remaining nine pages had not been supplied to him.

    He sent a demand for justice to the Customs authorities on February 27, 2024, seeking a complete copy of the order. Subsequently, he approached the High Court by filing the present writ petition in December 2024, seeking, among other reliefs, quashing of the adjudication proceedings and supply of the relevant records.

    Opposing the plea, the Customs authorities submitted that the adjudication order had already been dispatched to the petitioner's passport address on February 18, 2022, and that the allegations regarding non-supply of the order were baseless.

    After considering the rival submissions, the Court noted that the petitioner had received the Customs authorities' communication dated December 5, 2023, but did not raise any objection within a reasonable time. Even after sending the demand for justice on February 27, 2024, he waited almost ten months before approaching the High Court.

    "The entire chain of events clearly suggests that there has been delay and laches on the part of the petitioner in not raising his objection before the Authority in time," the Court observed.

    The Court further held that determining whether all ten pages of the adjudication order had actually been dispatched would involve deciding a disputed question of fact, which was not appropriate in the exercise of writ jurisdiction.

    Nevertheless, the Court directed the second respondent, the Joint Commissioner of Customs, to furnish a copy of the adjudication order dated February 17, 2022, to the petitioner within one week of receiving the order.

    Clarifying the scope of this direction, the Court stated that furnishing the copy would not create any equity in favour of the petitioner regarding the question of whether the Customs authorities had already served the adjudication order.

    Srinjoy Das

    Srinjoy Das is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Calcutta High Court

    Next Story