Employer's Denial Of Prior Employment Cannot Prevail Over Independent Provident Fund Records: Calcutta High Court

  • Justice Shampa (Dutt) Paul, Calcutta High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Calcutta High Court has held that an employer's denial of an employee's prior service cannot prevail over independent provident fund records corroborating his employment history.

    The High Court upheld a Labour Tribunal award in favour of a former Eastern Coalfields Limited (ECL) employee, whose appointment had been challenged by the company on the allegation that he had produced fabricated transfer documents.

    Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul) observed,

    “Independent records from the Coal Mines Provident Fund Office (Exhibits M-4 and M-5) confirm the workman's date of appointment as 22.03.1982 at Ajoy-II Colliery. Minor discrepancies in CMPF account numbering or administrative details generated by external authorities cannot be attributed as fraud on the part of the workman, although it reveals from the Award that there is no discrepancies in CMPF record.”

    Gouri Nath Banerjee was appointed in 1984 at Nakrakonda Colliery. Eastern Coalfields Limited contended that Banerjee got the appointment by producing fabricated documents to the effect that he had been transferred from Ajoy-II Colliery. It asserted that Banerjee never worked in Ajoy-II Colliery and that the transfer order and last pay certificate relied upon by Banerjee were false. Following an enquiry, Banerjee's service was terminated in 1996.

    Award of the Central Government Industrial Tribunal (CGIT), Asansol dated passed in 2023 directed Eastern Coalfield to treat Banerjee as continuing in service from the date of his dismissal, until his normal date of superannuation along with back wages and other service benefits.

    Before the High Court, Eastern Coalfield contended that there were inconsistencies in the PF records, and therefore, the award was liable to be set aside.

    It highlighted variation in the CMPF account number, a difference in the employee's father's name, and an absence of a transfer order in his favor. Further, it submitted that the original appointment documents have not been produced.

    The High Court referred to records maintained by an independent CMPF authority. It observed that the records formed the basis of the Tribunal's conclusion on Banerjee's prior employment.

    The High Court also noted that the employee had no control or influence over the records kept by that authority.

    Further, the High Court noted that Banerjee had worked at Nakrakonda Colliery for around ten years and had received two promotions during that period, which supports Tribunal's assessment of service history.

    Noting that the Eastern Coalfield's own witness had testified that no verification of the transfer order had been carried out, the Court ruled that the denial of Banerjee's prior employment could not outweigh the independent records relied on by the Tribunal.

    Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed.

    Date of Order: 12.10.2026

    For the Petitioner :Mr. Manik Das, Adv.

    For the Respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3 :Mr. Raj Kumar Gaurisaria, Adv. Ms. Sabita Roy, Adv.

    For the Respondent No.5 : Mr. Nirmalendu Ganguly, Adv. Mr. A. Chakraborty, Adv.

    Case Title :  Eastern Coalfields Limited v. Union of India & Ors.Case Number :  WPA 9805 of 2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (CAL) 265
    Next Story