16 Years After Two Boys Died In Open Sewer, Delhi High Court Directs DDA, DJB To Pay ₹11 Lakh Compensation Each
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
19 Nov 2026 11:51 AM IST

The Delhi High Court has directed the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and Delhi Jal Board (DJB) to pay compensation to the families of two boys who died after falling into an open sewer at a public park in city's Pitampura area in April 2010.
Justice Jasmeet Singh held both authorities responsible for negligence and directed them to pay ₹11.01 lakh to each family, along with 9% annual interest from the date of filing of the petitions, besides ₹1 lakh each towards litigation costs.
The Court observed that public authorities maintaining parks owe a heightened duty of care towards children, who cannot be expected to anticipate dangers in the same manner as adults.
"When any open sewer/manhole is situated in a public park, the maintaining authority owes a greater duty of care than required in ordinary cases," it said.
The case concerned the deaths of Robiyal, aged around 11-and-a-half years, and Arjun, aged around 12 years and nine months.
Their parents approached the High Court in 2016 seeking compensation, alleging that the deaths resulted from the negligence of the authorities responsible for maintaining the park and sewer infrastructure.
The DDA argued that although the park fell within its jurisdiction, the sewer work was being undertaken by DJB and therefore no negligence could be attributed to it.
Meanwhile, DJB contended that adequate safety precautions had been taken as the sewer structure was surrounded by walls approximately four to five feet high.
Rejecting DJB's defence, the Court observed that merely constructing boundary walls around an open sewer could not establish that adequate safety measures had been adopted.
"Children often perceive inadequately secured pits/areas as curious spaces and not as lethal dangers because owing to their age they lack foresight to protect themselves and they cannot be blamed for the same," it observed.
The Court also rejected DJB's reliance on the police cancellation report, which had attributed carelessness to the children for allegedly jumping over the walls.
It held that the findings in the report were untenable, observing that children playing in a public park could not be blamed for failing to appreciate the danger posed by structures left unsecured by public authorities.
The Court further clarified that the standard of proof for awarding compensation arising from the negligence of public authorities was different from that applicable in criminal proceedings.
As regards DDA, the Court held that it could not escape responsibility merely because the sewer work was being undertaken by another agency.
"The inter se dispute between respondent No. 1/DDA and respondent No. 2/DJB, cannot be an impediment for adjudication of the present matter and award of compensation," the Court said.
It applied the principle of res ipsa loquitur (the thing speaks for itself), holding that the undisputed circumstances surrounding the children's deaths gave rise to a presumption of negligence.
As such, the Court held DDA and DJB jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to both families.
For Petitioner: Mr. Siddharth, Adv.
For Respondents: Mr. Vaibhav Agnihotri, ASC with Mr. Vidit Pratap Singh, Mr. Ankit Singh, Advs. for Rl/ DDA Dr. Monika Arora, Mr. Subhrdeep Saha, Ms. Anamika Thakur, Mr. Abhinav Verma, Mr. Aradhya, Mr. Bhasker, Advs. for MCD

