Delhi High Court Admits Restaurants' Appeals Against Ban On Mandatory Service Charge, Grants No Interim Relief
Nupur Thapliyal
19 Nov 2026 1:21 PM IST

The Delhi High Court on Thursday admitted the appeals filed by restaurants against a single judge ruling which held that service charge and tips are voluntary payments by consumers and cannot be made compulsory or mandatory on food bills by restaurants or hotels.
The appeals have been filed by National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI).
A division bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma clarified that it has not passed any interim relief today in favour of the restaurants.
On Court's question as to why the service charge is not included in bills, the counsel appearing for one of the appellants said that restaurants voluntarily segregate service charge from overall bill because it is meant towards contribution to the staff.
On this, the Court remarked as to why hotels do not include all the charges in the food bill and why do they charge extra.
“Suppose you bring something of Rs. 100. You process it. You sell it for Rs. 1000. Do they come and question you from where this Rs. 900 come from? No. It is your processing fees…,” ACJ said.
He further remarked candidly: “In foreign countries, there are restaurants where they compel you that you must pay this much percentage of the bill as tip. This is not in our country. There is no legislation.”
As the Bench admitted the appeals, ASG Chetan Sharma said that notwithstanding the single judge passing a reasoned order and clarifying that restaurants do not have the power to levy tax, thousands of complaints have been received pan India from consumers that some restaurants are still charging service charge.
He said that earlier restaurants used to say that the appeals are pending and now, with appeals being admitted, they might still impose service charge.
On this, the Court said: “We haven't granted interim prayer.”
In March last year, the single judge rejected the pleas filed by the restaurant bodies challenging CCPA guidelines of 2022 prohibiting hotels and restaurants from levying service charges “automatically or by default” on food bills.
Upholding the guidelines, the single judge had dismissed the writ petitions with Rs. 1 lakh each to be deposited with CCPA for utilization for consumer welfare.
The single judge had clarified that mandatory collection of service charge on food bills is contrary to law and if consumers wish to pay any voluntary tip, the same is not barred. The amount however, ought not to be added by default in the bill/invoice and should be left to the customer's discretion, it added.
The single judge had observed that the manner of enforcement of payment of service charge is coercive in nature as in some cases, it is confused by the customers with service tax or a mandatory tax imposed by the government.
It had held that collecting a mandatory service charge as a matter of default without giving a choice to the consumer, cannot be contended to be contractually binding in nature.
The single judge had asked the CCPA to consider permitting change in the nomenclature for Service Charge which is nothing but a 'Tip or a gratuity or a voluntary contribution'. It said that terminology such as 'voluntary contribution', 'staff contribution', 'staff welfare fund' or similar terminology can be permitted.

