Delhi High Court Upholds Declaration Of Hindu Marriage As Void Amid Dispute Over Wife's Religious Identity
Nupur Thapliyal
19 Nov 2026 5:01 PM IST

The Delhi High Court has upheld a Family Court decree declaring a marriage between a Hindu man and a woman void ab initio under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, after finding that the woman had failed to substantiate her claim that she was a Hindu by birth.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar observed that the identity documents recording her name as a Muslim name and her father's name as “Shahid” contained erroneous entries.
The Bench dismissed the woman's appeal against the Family Court's order, which had declared her marriage with the husband, solemnised on July 15, 2024, invalid and void ab initio.
The Court observed that the woman had admitted the genuineness of several documents, including her Aadhaar card, CBSE Class X and XII certificates, bank records and employment documents, which consistently recorded her name as a Muslim name and also as daughter of Shahid @ Sayeed @ Saheed.
The woman had contended that her actual name was a Hindu name and that she was the daughter of one Manoj Kumar Gupta. According to her, her mother had earlier been married to Shahid, from whom she had two sons.
She said that after his death, her mother converted to Hinduism and married Manoj Kumar Gupta around 30-32 years ago. She claimed that she and her sister were born out of the latter marriage and brought up in a Hindu household.
She explained that her Muslim name and Shahid's name had been erroneously entered in her school records by her mother at the time of her admission, and the mistake was subsequently carried forward into her educational and other documents.
The husband, on the other hand, alleged that the woman had concealed her religious identity before marriage. He claimed that on August 12, 2024, he found her offering Namaz and that she subsequently told him that she was a practising Muslim and would require him to convert to Islam before they could have marital relations.
He further alleged that she left the matrimonial home on August 18, 2024, after he refused to convert.
The woman disputed the said allegations and maintained that the man and his family were aware of her family background and the discrepancies in her documents before the marriage.
The husband subsequently approached the Family Court seeking a declaration that the marriage was void, contending that the Hindu Marriage Act could not apply to a marriage between a Hindu and a Muslim.
The Family Court allowed his application under Order XII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which permits a court to pass a judgment on the basis of admissions, and declared the marriage void.
In appeal, the Bench found no ground to interfere with the Family Court's decision. It observed that the documentary record was not confined to a single school document but comprised records issued or maintained by independent authorities and institutions, including Aadhaar, PAN, CBSE, banks and her employer.
“The consistent mentioning of her name as Yasmeen in these records over a substantial period lends support to the Respondent's case and cannot be brushed aside merely by describing the entries as an inadvertent error,” the Court observed.
It further noted that the woman's bank and employment records reflected the Muslim name even around the time of the marriage in 2024.
The Court also declined to treat the paternity report dated November 24, 2025, as conclusive proof, observing that it had not been obtained pursuant to any direction of a competent court and that the samples had not been collected under judicial supervision.
It further noted that the woman had not produced any birth certificate, contemporaneous official record or other cogent documentary material establishing that Manoj Kumar Gupta was her father.
Finding that the woman had failed to substantiate her asserted identity and parentage through reliable material, the Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Family Court's decree declaring the marriage void ab initio.

