Selection Process Can't Be Cancelled Merely Because Only One Candidate Appeared For Interview: Gauhati High Court
Bhavya Singh
18 Nov 2026 7:50 PM IST

The Gauhati High Court has held that a candidate who has appeared for an interview and has been found fit for appointment cannot be penalised merely because other eligible candidates did not appear for the interview.
Justice Rajesh Mazumdar observed in,
"In my considered opinion, the petitioner cannot be penalized with a cancellation of an interview process, which she diligently faced, only on the ground that other candidates preferred not to appear on the due date of the selection process."
The observation came in a writ petition filed by one Dr Nandita Paul under Article 226 of the Constitution, challenging the cancellation of the selection process for the post of Assistant Professor in Bengali at Gurucharan College, Silchar, pursuant to an advertisement dated August 7, 2016.
As per the records of the College authorities, 17 applications were received for the post, of which eight candidates, including the petitioner, were found eligible and issued call letters for document verification and interview. Only the petitioner appeared before the Selection Committee on November 17, 2022, and was found fit and qualified for appointment.
Her name was forwarded to the Director of Higher Education, Assam, through the Governing Body of the College. However, her appointment was kept pending following a complaint recommended for investigation by the Education Minister. Subsequently, the Director permitted re-advertisement of the post on the ground that only one candidate had appeared for the interview.
The petitioner submitted that no irregularity or illegality had been alleged in the selection process and that she could not be held responsible for the absence of other candidates. The College authorities maintained that all eligible candidates had been issued call letters and that due procedure had been followed.
The Higher Education Department, however, contended that the selection process lacked "healthy competition" since only one candidate had participated, and that re-advertisement was necessary to ensure fairness in public employment.
The High Court noted that the Director of Higher Education had not alleged any illegality or irregularity in the selection process and had referred only to the absence of "healthy competition". It was also not the respondents' case that eligible candidates had not been called for the interview or that any leniency had been shown towards the petitioner.
The Court observed, "In my considered opinion, when candidates who have applied for a particular post do not appear in the interview process, despite being called upon to do so, the candidates who appear in the interview and are evaluated cannot be faulted for the absence of other candidates."
The Court further held that the absence of healthy competition could have been considered had there been a complete absence of applications or had call letters not been dispatched to eligible and qualified candidates. In the present case, however, eligible candidates had responded to the advertisement and had been intimated and required to appear for the interview.
Justice Mazumdar observed,
"However, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, when the eligibility and qualifications of the petitioner are not an issue, and the only reason is the absence of other candidates despite being informed of the date of interview, it would be unfair and against equity to deny the petitioner a fair chance of consideration for the post for which she had applied and participated in the interview."
The Court held that the proposal of the Selection Committee to offer appointment to the petitioner deserved to be taken to its logical conclusion, without reference to the absence of candidates who had chosen not to participate in the selection process.
Accordingly, the High Court allowed the writ petition and interfered with the directions issued by the Director of Higher Education requiring fresh re-advertisement of the post.
It directed the Director to process the proposal forwarded by the Selection Committee in accordance with law and grant final approval within four weeks from receipt of a certified copy of the order, in the absence of any impediment. If any impediment existed, the petitioner was to be informed within the same period and afforded an opportunity to rectify it.

