'Photographic Memory': J&K&L High Court Relies On 8-Yr-Old Rape Survivor's Detailed Account To Uphold Conviction

  • Photographic Memory: J&K&L High Court Relies On 8-Yr-Old Rape Survivors Detailed Account To Uphold Conviction

    The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has upheld the conviction of a man sentenced to 14 years' rigorous imprisonment for raping his eight-year-old niece, holding that the child's consistent and "photographic memory" supported by medical evidence, was sufficient to establish his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.A Division Bench of Justice Sanjay Dhar and Justice Shahzad Azeem dismissed...

    The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has upheld the conviction of a man sentenced to 14 years' rigorous imprisonment for raping his eight-year-old niece, holding that the child's consistent and "photographic memory" supported by medical evidence, was sufficient to establish his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

    A Division Bench of Justice Sanjay Dhar and Justice Shahzad Azeem dismissed the appeal filed by convict, observing that the child had given a coherent and detailed account of the assault and had withstood cross-examination despite her tender age.

    Describing the child's recollection of the incident, the Bench observed, “The quality of her recollection is that of photographic memory.” It noted that she remembered minute details, including the game she was playing, the room where the assault took place, the sequence of events and even the clothes she was wearing.

    "These minute, consistent details given by a child witness after a considerable time from the occurrence demonstrate that the occurrence was firmly imprinted in her memory and was not reconstructed or improved upon. The trial court held that her statement inspired confidence precisely because of this consistency and the absence of any material contradiction".

    It attached significance to the manner in which the child identified the appellant as “Sanju Chachu”, observing that this was a natural familial expression rather than an indication of hostility or tutoring.

    The Court remarked,

    “The absence of any venom, exaggeration or attempt to blacken the accused beyond specific act, and her categorical denial of any land dispute or tutoring, reinforces that her testimony is not the product of personal animus or parental coaching.”

    The Court also relied upon the medical findings of a torn hymen, a vaginal wall tear requiring stitches and bleeding, observing that the combination of the child's testimony and the contemporaneous medical evidence left little room for doubt about the occurrence.

    Background

    The prosecution case was that on April 23, 2017, the eight-year-old child had gone to the appellant's house to play hide-and-seek with his children. The appellant, who was her uncle and lived in the neighbourhood, allegedly took her into a room in a tin-shed structure, closed the door and sexually assaulted her. Subsequently an FIR was lodged under Sections 376 and 342 of the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC).

    The Additional Sessions Judge, Udhampur, convicted the appellant and sentenced him to 14 years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹1 lakh; against this accused moved the high court.

    Court's Observation

    The Bench began by reiterating that the testimony of a prosecutrix, if found reliable and trustworthy, can by itself sustain a conviction in a sexual assault case. Corroboration, it observed, is not a requirement of law but a matter of prudence depending upon the facts of each case.

    Examining the child's deposition, the Court found that she had consistently narrated how the appellant took her into the room, closed the door and sexually assaulted her. She had also described the subsequent conduct of the appellant, including his following her home and pouring water over her.

    The Bench noted that despite detailed cross-examination, the child remained firm in her account and specifically denied the defence suggestions that she had been tutored by her parents or that the allegation arose out of a land dispute.

    The Bench then highlighted the detailed recollection demonstrated by the child during her testimony. She remembered the game of hide-and-seek, the names of the children with whom she was playing, the nature of the room, the sequence of events, the clothes she was wearing and the appellant's conduct after the incident.

    It observed that these details demonstrated that the occurrence was firmly imprinted in her memory and had not been reconstructed or improved upon.

    The Court also found that the child's testimony was supported by the evidence of her mother, father and Ajay Kumar, who had taken the family to the police station and thereafter to the hospital.

    Of particular significance was the medical evidence. Dr. Sanjay Verma, the gynaecologist who examined the child on the same day, had found that her posterior fourchette and hymen were torn, that she had suffered a first-degree vaginal wall tear requiring stitches, and that there was bleeding per vaginum. On the basis of the clinical findings and histopathological examination of the vaginal smear, the doctor opined that the child had experienced sexual intercourse within 12 hours of the examination.

    The Bench held that the medical findings were consistent with the child's account of penetration and resulting trauma. It observed,

    “The combination of a sterling statement by a child victim and supporting medical evidence leaves little room for doubt regarding the occurrence of the incident.”

    The Court also rejected the defence challenge based on the delay in recording the statements of the prosecutrix and her parents. It noted that the child's statement had been recorded after 14 days, while the statements of her parents were recorded after 23 to 24 days.

    The Investigating Officers had explained that they were occupied with the arrest of the accused and other investigation-related duties. One of the Investigating Officers had also stated that the case file indicated that the child was not fit to make a statement at the relevant time, although this had not been specifically recorded by the earlier officers. Accepting these explanations, the Bench held,

    “The explanations offered are plausible and consistent with the ordinary course of investigation, particularly in a case involving arrest of the accused and other urgent steps.”

    It accordingly concluded that the delay, by itself, did not cast doubt on the credibility of the prosecution version.

    The Bench further found no material discrepancy in the sequence in which the child was taken to the police station and hospital. The evidence established that the family had first approached the police station for registration of the FIR and thereafter proceeded to the hospital for medical examination.

    It emphasised that minor discrepancies and inconsistencies do not undermine an otherwise reliable prosecution case, particularly when the core account is supported by medical evidence.

    Upon a cumulative appraisal of the evidence, the High Court concluded that the prosecution had established the appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt. It found that the child's testimony was coherent, natural and consistent, that she had withstood cross-examination, and that her account was corroborated by the witnesses who had seen her immediately after the occurrence as well as by the contemporaneous medical findings.

    The Bench held that the discrepancies relied upon by the defence and the delay in recording the statements had been satisfactorily explained and did not affect the core of the prosecution case. It also found that the allegation of false implication on account of a land dispute remained unsupported.

    Holding that the conviction under Sections 376 and 342 RPC was fully justified, the Court dismissed the appeal.

    Next Story